So, with the #12 pick overall in the 2012 draft, the Mets drafted SS Gavin Cecchini from Barbe HS Louisiana.
Baseball Prospectus‘ Kevin Goldstein on Cecchini, who he ranked #17 pre-draft:
The younger brother of Red Sox third baseman Garin, but a very different player. Gavin is smaller and more athletic, and a plus defensive shortstop who should stay at the position all the way up the ladder. He’s a plus runner as well, and has outstanding baseball instincts. While Garin is arguably the best pure hitter in the Red Sox system, Gavin comes with questions about his bat. He has a smooth line drive stroke but little projection for power, so he’ll have to develop a good approach to find his secondary skills.
Baseball America on Cecchini, who they ranked #16 pre-draft:
Wiry at 6-foot-1, 185 pounds, Cecchini’s best attributes are his steadiness and defensive skills at shortstop. He has good hands and feet as well as the infield actions to stay at short, and excels at cutoff throws and being in the right spot defensively. His arm strength is a tick above-average and unfailingly accurate. His speed is about the same and plays up like his arm–he’s a skilled baserunner who takes extra bases and steals bases intelligently. Cecchini’s bat involves some projection, though. Some scouts believe he will be a bottom-of-the-order hitter despite his polished approach because of a lack of strength and impact bat speed. Cecchini is one of the safer bets in the high school class due to his polish, but scouts are mixed on his true upside.
ESPN.com (Keith Law and Kiley McDaniel) on Cecchini who they ranked #18 pre-draft:
Cecchini, the younger brother of Red Sox farmhand, Garin, has a better chance to stay at shortstop than his brother did while sharing the same solid makeup and strong feel for the game.
Gavin Cecchini starts with a very wide base at the plate and gets wider as he strides — far wider than he did last summer — leaving himself somewhat off balance through contact, although closing his initial stance could mitigate this. His siwng is somewhat rotational with slight loft but not the kind that will produce big power; it’s not great bat speed but his hand-eye appears to be very strong, and getting him more balanced at the plate should improve his contact rates and doubles power with wood. In the field, Cecchini has a plus arm with a very quick release, soft hands, and the agility to be anabove-average defender at short in pro ball.
There’s a utility-player floor here that makes him somewhat safer than most high-school picks, but I’d be surprised if that’s all he turns out to be.