So, J.P. Ricciardi, huh?

Yesterday, the Mets announced that they hired J.P Ricciardi as a Special Assistant to GM Sandy Alderson.  It’s a reunion.  Ricciardi held the same post under Alderson in Oakland before becoming the Director of Player Personnel for Billy Beane and then later the GM of the Blue Jays in November 2001.

Ricciardi is one of Alderson’s guys.  He suggested to the media that he was leaning towards taking a job with Boston, until Alderson called him.  As quoted by Adam Rubin at ESPNNY, Ricciardi said of the Boston gig, “I was going to head that direction until Sandy got the job.”

Ricciardi lasted eight years with the Toronto Blue Jays when Rogers Communications owned the team.  The GM of the Blue Jays from the years 2001-2009 had to be one of the most toughest in sports because he was competing first with the Yankee Dynasty and then the mini Evil Empire Red Sox with a fraction of the budget.  Ricciardi did not have much success in the role.  However, he made his own life difficult with a string of bad contracts.

Something to like:
Ricciardi comes from a player development and scouting background.  Here’s his mini-bio from Wikipedia:

After the conclusion of his playing career, Ricciardi became a coach in the New York Yankees farm system in the early 1980s before joining the Oakland Athletics organization in 1986 as a minor league instructor and scout. By the early 1990s he had risen to the rank of East Coast Scouting Supervisor and later National Crosschecker. Ricciardi made his break into the front office in 1996, when he became special assistant to Athletics general manager Sandy Alderson. Under new general manager Billy Beane, who was hired in 1997 and had been Ricciardi’s former teammate with the Little Falls Mets,[2] his role became Director of Player Personnel.

Scary Things:
– Ricciardi gave out some terrible contracts in Toronto:

  • Alex Rios: 7 years, $69.835 million (with a $13.5 M club option in 2015 with a 1 M buyout)
    • Coming off consecutive All-Star appearances in 2006 and 2007, the team saved almost $3 M in 2008, in exchange for albatross payments of $12 M beginning in 2011.  Rios, a career .284/.334/.457 hitter, has never appeared in another All-Star game.  The Blue Jays simply put him on waivers in 2009.  I’m sure the White Sox, who claimed him, are stoked about the $50 million they owe him over the next four years for his age 30-33 seasons.
  • BJ Ryan – 5 years, $47 million
    • Ryan was tremendous in 2004 and 2005 in his age 28 and 29 seasons for Baltimore, so the Jays overpaid him in the winter of 2005.  He rewarded them with a dominant 2006 with a 1.37 ERA and 86 strikeouts in 72.1 innings.  Then his elbow fell apart.  He needed Tommy John surgery after five games in 2007.  He was solid in 2008 (2.95 ERA, 28 BB, 58 K in 58 IP) but terrible enough in 2009 to earn his release.  This time, no one rushed in to claim his contract, and the Jays were left paying him $10 million in 2010 to sit on the couch.
  • Vernon Wells – 7 years, $126 million
    • The worst contract in baseball?  Or does that insult Brian Sabean and Barry Zito?
    • That’s $23 mil in 2011, $21 mil in 2012, 13, and 2014 all for a guy who hit .273/.331/.515 this year with 31 homers, matching his age in 2010.  So, he’ll earn at least $21 mil in as a 32-35 year old.
  • AJ Burnett – 5 years, $55 million
    • The good news for Toronto was that Burnett opted out of this goofiness after 2008 to sign an even goofier 5 year/$82.5 million contract with the Yankees.
  • Lyle Overbay – 4 years, $24 million
    • Signed in January ’07 when Overbay was coming off a career year at .312/.372/.508 in his age 29 season.  It was the only time in his career his slugging percentage reached .500
  • Frank Thomas – 2 years, $18 million with a $10 million option for 2009
    • I love Frank Thomas.  I loved that he hit .270/.381/.545 for Oakland while earning $500K in 2006 at age 38.  I have no idea how committing $18 million to a player in his age 39 and 40 seasons, could have been construed as a good idea in the winter of 2006.  It wasn’t.  Thomas was released in the spring of 2008 so the Jays wouldn’t be tempted to play him and see his option, which was based on plate appearances vest.

Mets fans rightly were critical of Omar Minaya for the Oliver Perez and Luis Castillo contracts.  But Ricciardi’s record of overpayments is really amazin’.  Paying this much money for guys who were past their prime is really a spectacular misread of player value and the market.

The Lies
When you don’t tell the truth, it’s called lying.

  • Ricciardi initially told the media that B.J. Ryan was suffering from a back problem.  Instead, Ryan had an elbow problem that eventually needed Tommy John Surgery.  Busted, he dropped his infamous, “They’re not lies if we know the truth,” line that surely made George Orwell proud.
  • He ripped Adam Dunn for not liking baseball, and then claimed to apologize to Dunn, while Dunn claimed he’d never heard from Ricciardi.  Huh?
    • Here’s his quote about Dunn:

Do you know the guy doesn’t really like baseball that much? Do you know the guy doesn’t have a passion to play the game that much? How much do you know about the player? There’s a reason why you’re attracted to some players and there’s a reason why you’re not attracted to some players. I don’t think you’d be very happy if we brought Adam Dunn here …

Joe Posnanski wrote a great piece about Ricciardi last August.

There are parts of his record that are really scary.  On the other hand, now, Ricciardi won’t be running the show, just advising.

Maybe Ricciardi is better suited for whatever reason to be someone’s sidekick rather than the top guy.  Maybe this is the right situation for him as Alderson’s helper.  Maybe he’s learned from his big-budget mistakes.  Maybe now he’ll be honest with the media.
Maybe, maybe, maybe.

There are 13 comments

  1. MackeySasser

    I agree most of those contracts were awful but lets remember playing in Toronto you need to overpay sometimes. Frank Thomas was coming off a season where he had a .926 OPS in Oakland and actually had 95 rbi and 26 homers with an .857 OPS his first year in Toronto (good production for his 9 million a year pricetag). Burnett was signed as a 29 year old coming off 2 strong “seasons” in Florida. He posted a 3.53 era 1.22 whip with 8.5 k/9 and 114 era+ in 51 starts from 2004-2005. At the time people believed Burnett had “turned the corner”. BJ Ryan was a dominant closer/setup man his last 2 seasons in Baltimore which is why he got his 4 years 47 million dollar deal. Many people thought it was a “steal” compared to the age/price on Wagner. He got hurt (and JP’s handling of it was poor) but I don’t think in comparison to what other closers were getting that it was a terrible deal. Ricciardi also drafted a LOT of good young talent while in Toronto including Romero, Cecil and Marcum (Romero and Marcum would be #1 starters on the Mets) as well as guys like Aaron Hill and Adam Lind. Again, I agree with your overall theme but I think some of these are sort of unfair.

    1. Toby Hyde

      That’s the thing about long-term deals to guys who aren’t elite players: they might look good for a year or two, but in the end, they’re bad investments.

      1. mark4212

        This was also during the steroid era when Guys like Barry bonds, sammy sosa, Rafael Palermio are all having superb seasons in the 33+ age bracket among the 100’s of others.

        He totally mis-read the market on those contracts but his draft record from 2003-2006 was pretty solid.

        2003 – 1st round Aaron Hill 3rd round Shawn Marcum
        2004 – 3rd round Adam Lind, 4th round Casey Janssen 24th round Jesse Litsch
        2005 – Ricky Romero 1st round

  2. MackeySasser

    I neglected to mention that Burnett actually pitched quite well in Toronto posting a 3.94 era and 1.28 whip over 80 starts despite pitching in the AL East. A guy like that surely would be looking at a deal similar to what he got from the Blue Jays in his new deal (Yankees gave him even more)

  3. Bren

    Even though Romero has developed nicely, taking him over Tulowitzki in 2006 is still a head scratcher. Like Toby said though, he’s not in charge here and should be in a position where his strengths are utilized better…

    This is supposed to be the best draft since sliced bread, so hopefully they intend to cast a wide net. I have a hard time imagining them using the same draft team, and I do feel better knowing that guys like Riccardi and Krivsky will be involved. I would still like to see Omar utilized on the Latin side too, though I know he might not want to and prospects will ultimately go to the money in the end…

  4. Tvators1

    Also Rios kinda bounced back last yr, plus CFers who hit .284/.334/.457, 21, 88, 34 don’t grow on trees, which Mets fans will realize once Beltran is run outta town and labeled a disappointment. Then mets fans can go back to watching the likes of Esix Snead, Gerald Williams, Jeff Duncan and Joe McEwing patrol CF at Citi and then maybe we’ll realize how good beltran’s been.

    1. theperfectgame

      I agree that Beltran is generally underappreciated, but Angel Pagan (presumptively the Mets’ next CF) is a pretty far cry from Esix Snead…

  5. Tvators1

    Presumably, yes. I know. Got to figured Mets keep Beltran in CF at least initially next year, to hopefully maximize his value if we are as expected not competing w/ Philly & Braves come July maybe we can get something for him. I lke Angel as much as anyone, but to presume in 2012, Pagan will be healthy and suceeding is presumptious…hopefully one of kirk, Cecilini, Puello, Van Dekker develop enough to be the future in CF.

  6. WC

    Burnett and Rios contracts weren’t that terrible. Ryan’s was, and was a good lesson to everyone that paying a reliever a lot of money over 5 years is silly.

    Vernon Wells is completely indefensible.

    Ricciardi brings lots of positives though.

    1. theperfectgame

      Omar Minaya then offered a refresher course on that lesson in the 2008-09 offseason, demonstrating that the conclusion holds for 4-year (or 3-year+option) contracts as well.

  7. ergsergh

    The new year approaching, click in. Let’s facelift bar!

    fr ee sh i pp ing

    (jordan shoes) $32

    (air max) $34


    ▍ ★∴
       ....▍▍....█▍ ☆ ★∵ …./

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s