Does Jimmy Blame Howard For Chucks Death?

This article may contain affiliate links. For details, visit our Affiliate Disclosure page.


The death of Chuck McGill, an enigmatic character in the acclaimed television series “Better Call Saul,” left viewers grappling with numerous questions and contemplating the complex dynamics between the show’s central characters. One intriguing aspect that has fueled intense debates among fans is whether Jimmy McGill (later known as Saul Goodman) holds Howard Hamlin responsible for Chuck’s tragic demise. The intricate web of emotions, actions, and circumstances surrounding this question offers a captivating glimpse into the human psyche and the multifaceted nature of blame. In this article, we delve deep into Jimmy’s mindset, exploring his thoughts, actions, and the undeniable tensions with Howard, all while attempting to answer the thought-provoking question: Does Jimmy blame Howard for Chuck’s death?

Does Jimmy Blame Howard For Chucks Death?

The Foundation of Resentment:

Jimmy’s Betrayal: A Catalyst for Discord

Chuck’s death acted as a catalyst that intensified the already simmering resentment between Jimmy and Howard. However, to understand the depth of Jimmy’s sentiments, we must examine the foundation of their animosity. Jimmy’s transformation from a morally ambiguous yet lovable character to a hardened criminal lawyer stemmed from a series of betrayals. When Jimmy faced disciplinary action for his misdeeds, he expected Howard to intercede and fight for his reinstatement. Instead, Howard disavowed any responsibility, leading to a permanent rift between the two characters.

The seeds of blame may have taken root during this pivotal moment. Jimmy could perceive Howard’s lack of support as a betrayal not just of their friendship, but also of the implicit promise to stand by him in times of trouble. This betrayal, coupled with the pre-existing envy Jimmy harbored towards Howard’s seemingly perfect life, laid the foundation for a deep-seated resentment that would shape their interactions in the aftermath of Chuck’s death.

Chuck’s Tragic Demise: The Burden of Guilt

The death of Jimmy’s older brother, Chuck, ushered in a maelstrom of emotions that further complicated his relationship with Howard. Despite their strained dynamics, Jimmy had always respected Chuck’s legal acumen and sought his approval. When Chuck took his own life, the weight of guilt settled heavily on Jimmy’s shoulders, forcing him to confront the lingering question of whether his actions inadvertently pushed his brother to such a tragic end.

In this fragile state of mourning, it’s natural for Jimmy to look for someone to blame. While the circumstances surrounding Chuck’s death were complex, Howard Hamlin’s name inevitably resurfaced as a possible scapegoat. Jimmy might have asked himself if Howard’s unwillingness to support him in his times of need ultimately contributed to the chain of events that led to Chuck’s demise. This internal struggle, mixed with guilt and grief, could have sparked a desire to hold Howard accountable, laying the groundwork for a growing sense of blame.

The Ebb and Flow of Jimmy’s Blame:

The Culmination of a Failed Friendship: Strained Professional Relations

Jimmy and Howard’s professional relationship reached its breaking point long before Chuck’s death, making it a fertile ground for the development of blame. As Chuck’s trusted confidant and legal adversary, Howard found himself positioned as a constant reminder of Jimmy’s past failures and unfulfilled potential. Howard’s success, stature, and control over Jimmy’s future legal career amplified Jimmy’s feelings of inadequacy, contributing to a toxic brew of envy and resentment.

With the weight of Chuck’s death hanging over them, the professional tension between Jimmy and Howard escalated. Each interaction became a battleground, filled with veiled accusations and underlying hostilities. Jimmy’s blame for Howard may not solely stem from the events surrounding Chuck’s demise, but rather from a culmination of years of strained relations, where Howard became a symbolic representation of all that went wrong in Jimmy’s life.

The Lingering Ghost: Chuck’s Influence on Blame

Chuck’s absence did not diminish his presence in the lives of those he left behind. Even in death, Chuck’s influence reverberated through Jimmy’s actions and mindset, adding another layer to the question of blame. Jimmy’s perception of Howard’s role in Chuck’s downfall might have been distorted by his unwavering loyalty and love for his late brother. Blaming Howard for Chuck’s death could serve as a way for Jimmy to externalize his guilt and protect his cherished memories of his brother.

Furthermore, Chuck’s own belief that Howard orchestrated his professional downfall could have subtly influenced Jimmy’s perception. Jimmy, aware of Chuck’s deep-rooted disdain for Howard, may have internalized those beliefs, intertwining them with his own feelings of betrayal and resentment. In this tangled web of emotions, the line between personal conviction and inherited blame becomes blurred, making it increasingly challenging to disentangle Jimmy’s true sentiments towards Howard.


The question of whether Jimmy blames Howard for Chuck’s death presents a complex tapestry of emotions, motivations, and circumstances that intertwine to shape Jimmy’s perspective. The betrayal and strained professional relations between the two characters, coupled with the profound guilt and grief Jimmy experiences in the wake of his brother’s suicide, contribute to a nuanced understanding of his sentiments. As the series progresses, viewers are left to navigate the depths of Jimmy’s character and the intricate web of blame that surrounds Howard. The dynamic between these two characters continues to evolve, leaving fans eagerly anticipating the next chapter in this captivating narrative.

Does Jimmy Blame Howard For Chucks Death?
Scroll to top