How much of American Cheese is actual Cheese?

This article may contain affiliate links. For details, visit our Affiliate Disclosure page.


In the realm of cheese, American cheese has always held a peculiar position. Loved by many and derided by purists, it has carved a unique niche for itself on the palates of millions. But amidst its popularity, a lingering question persists: How much of American cheese is actual cheese? This enigma calls for a deeper exploration into the nature of American cheese, its composition, and the factors that define its classification. In this article, we embark on a journey to demystify the origins and essence of American cheese, unraveling its secrets, and shedding light on the intriguing world of this beloved dairy delight.

How much of American Cheese is actual Cheese?

I. American Cheese: An Enigmatic Creation

  1. The Birth of American Cheese:
    Behind the curtains of American cheese lies a fascinating history that traces its roots to the 19th century. During this time, European immigrants flocked to the United States, each bringing with them their unique cheese-making traditions. However, the quest to create a cheese that would cater to the American palate spurred the birth of a distinctly American cheese.

The amalgamation of various cheese-making techniques led to the emergence of a process known as “processed cheese.” This innovative method involved blending different cheeses, adding emulsifiers and stabilizers, and subjecting them to heat, resulting in a smooth and consistent texture. The birth of processed cheese marked the inception of what would eventually become the foundation of American cheese.

  1. Defining American Cheese:
    As the lines blurred between traditional cheese and processed cheese, a clear definition of American cheese became necessary. The United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) established stringent regulations that outline the requirements for a cheese to be labeled as “American cheese.” These standards ensure a minimum percentage of cheese solids, typically ranging from 51% to 99%, depending on the specific type of American cheese.

However, it is important to note that not all American cheese is created equal. Within the realm of American cheese, there exist variations such as “Pasteurized Process American Cheese” and “Pasteurized Process Cheese Food.” These distinctions depend on the specific blend of cheese, additives, and moisture content, each with its own classification under FDA guidelines.

II. Deconstructing the Composition

  1. Cheese Solids and Additives:
    To truly understand the composition of American cheese, one must delve into its intricate components. Cheese solids refer to the protein and fat content derived from cheese. While traditional cheese relies solely on these components, American cheese often incorporates additives such as emulsifiers, stabilizers, flavor enhancers, and colorants.

Emulsifiers, such as sodium phosphate, aid in the blending and smoothness of the cheese, preventing the separation of fat and moisture. Stabilizers, like sodium citrate, contribute to the cheese’s firmness and texture. Flavor enhancers, including salt and artificial flavors, help create the distinctive taste associated with American cheese. Lastly, colorants like annatto give American cheese its characteristic orange hue.

  1. Processing Techniques:
    The journey of American cheese involves a series of intricate processing techniques that set it apart from traditional cheese-making methods. The initial step involves shredding or grinding the cheese solids, which are then combined with additives and emulsifiers. Heat is applied to melt the cheese, resulting in a molten mass that undergoes further mixing and blending.

The final product is cooled rapidly to create the desired texture, which can range from a sliceable consistency to a softer, spreadable form. The packaging of American cheese ensures its preservation, maintaining its freshness and extending its shelf life. The precise execution of these processing techniques defines the character and integrity of American cheese.

III. The Controversy Surrounding American Cheese

  1. The Authenticity Debate:
    American Cheese has long been a subject of heated debates among cheese connoisseurs and purists. The inclusion of additives and processing techniques in American cheese has sparked controversy, with critics arguing that it deviates from the traditional art of cheese-making. They question whether American cheese can truly be considered “real cheese.”

On the other hand, proponents of American cheese argue that it is a unique culinary creation that has its own place in the world of cheese. They emphasize the distinct flavors, versatility, and convenience that American cheese offers. They believe that while it may not align with traditional cheese-making methods, it has carved a niche for itself and remains beloved by many.

  1. Nutritional Considerations:
    In addition to the authenticity debate, there are also concerns surrounding the nutritional aspects of American cheese. The inclusion of additives, such as sodium and artificial flavors, has led to criticisms about its health implications. Some argue that the higher sodium content and processed nature of American cheese make it less nutritious compared to traditional cheese.

However, it is essential to note that American cheese, like any other food, can be enjoyed in moderation as part of a balanced diet. The nutritional value of American cheese varies depending on the specific type and brand, and consumers can make informed choices based on their dietary needs and preferences.

IV. Embracing the Allure of American Cheese

  1. Culinary Versatility:
    One undeniable aspect of American cheese is its versatility in the culinary world. Its smooth texture and mild flavor make it an excellent choice for melting, making it a staple ingredient in classic comfort foods like grilled cheese sandwiches and cheeseburgers. American cheese’s ability to melt consistently without separating makes it a preferred choice for achieving that perfect oozy, gooey texture.

Moreover, American cheese’s malleability allows for easy incorporation into various dishes. It can be sliced, diced, or shredded, making it an ideal topping for burgers, salads, and casseroles. Its creamy texture also lends itself well to dips and spreads, adding a delectable touch to party platters.

  1. Iconic Pop Culture Status:
    American cheese has achieved an iconic status in popular culture, solidifying its place in the hearts and minds of Americans. From its prominent presence in fast-food chains to its association with comfort food, American cheese has become a symbol of nostalgia and familiarity. It represents a taste of home, evoking childhood memories and a sense of culinary heritage.


The world of American cheese is a captivating blend of tradition, innovation, controversy, and culinary allure. As we have explored in this article, American cheese is a product of its unique history, intricate composition, and distinct processing techniques. While it may differ from traditional cheese-making methods, it has found its own place on the plates and in the hearts of cheese lovers across America.

The question of how much of American cheese is actual cheese has been answered through an examination of its cheese solids, additives, and processing techniques. American cheese, with its blend of cheese solids, emulsifiers, stabilizers, flavor enhancers, and colorants, stands as a distinct and beloved creation. So, the next time you enjoy a melty grilled cheese sandwich or savor a cheeseburger topped with American cheese, remember the journey and artistry that went into creating this unique dairy delight. American cheese may have its critics, but it continues to hold its own as a beloved and iconic symbol of American culinary culture.

How much of American Cheese is actual Cheese?
Scroll to top