If you’re a shake lover who values quality and authenticity, this list is for you. Not all fast-food or casual dining chains use real ice cream in their shakes—some opt for ice cream mix or frozen dairy desserts instead. Here, we highlight seven popular chains that proudly serve shakes made with genuine ice cream, providing a richer, creamier experience that true dessert fans will appreciate.
Shake Shack
Shake Shack’s shakes are famously creamy because they use real custard-style ice cream. Their custard is made fresh daily in their own facilities, using high-quality milk and cream with no artificial growth hormones. This results in a dense, rich shake that’s thicker and more flavorful than typical fast-food shakes, making it a favorite for those who want authenticity in every sip.
Steak ’n Shake
Steak ’n Shake is well-known for its classic diner-style shakes made from real ice cream. Their shakes come in a variety of traditional flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry, all crafted using a proprietary blend of ice cream that has been a staple since the 1930s. The chain’s commitment to quality ice cream helps maintain that nostalgic, indulgent shake taste that sets them apart.
Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers
Freddy’s serves frozen custard shakes made from a blend of real milk, cream, and egg yolks, which differentiates their shakes from those made with standard ice cream. Frozen custard is denser and creamier due to the egg yolks, giving Freddy’s shakes a unique, velvety texture. This custard base is freshly churned every two hours, ensuring freshness and consistency in every shake.
Dairy Queen (DQ)
While Dairy Queen’s signature Blizzard is made with soft serve, their traditional shakes are crafted using their signature DQ ice cream blend, which is a high-quality frozen dairy product. The ice cream used in their shakes contains real milk and cream, delivering a creamy texture distinct from other fast-food shake options. DQ’s shakes maintain a classic, smooth consistency that has made them a staple in many communities.
Portillo’s
Famous for Chicago-style fast food, Portillo’s shakes are made with real ice cream sourced from local dairies to ensure freshness and quality. Their shakes are thick, creamy, and rich, with popular flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry that complement their menu of hot dogs and Italian beef sandwiches. Portillo’s commitment to real dairy ingredients elevates their shakes beyond typical fast-food offerings.
Andy’s Frozen Custard
Andy’s Frozen Custard uses a custard base made with real eggs, cream, and milk, resulting in a shake that is denser and creamier than those made with just ice cream. Their custard is churned fresh daily, and their shakes are hand-spun to order, ensuring a rich texture and fresh taste. Known for their generous portion sizes, Andy’s shakes deliver a satisfying indulgence for custard aficionados.
McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams
McConnell’s is a premium ice cream brand with several scoop shops and cafes, and their shakes are made exclusively with their own small-batch, handmade ice cream. Using fresh, locally sourced cream and milk, McConnell’s shakes are exceptionally rich and flavorful, free from artificial stabilizers or preservatives. Their artisanal approach results in shakes that taste like a true homemade treat, prized by ice cream purists.
How to Choose
When selecting a chain for real ice cream shakes, consider the base ingredient first—real ice cream or custard versus frozen dairy dessert or soft serve. Real ice cream and custard use higher milk fat content and fewer additives, providing a creamier texture and richer flavor. Also, freshness matters: chains that churn or make their ice cream or custard in-house or source from local dairies tend to offer a superior taste. Finally, flavor variety and portion size can influence your experience, so choose a chain that fits your flavor preferences and desired indulgence level.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do all fast-food chains use real ice cream in their shakes?
No, many use ice cream mix, frozen dairy dessert, or soft serve, which often contain stabilizers and less milk fat.
What’s the difference between ice cream and frozen custard in shakes?
Frozen custard contains egg yolks in addition to milk and cream, making it denser and creamier than standard ice cream.
Are shakes made with real ice cream healthier?
Not necessarily; real ice cream shakes often have higher fat and calorie content, but they avoid some additives found in mixes.
Can I find real ice cream shakes at national chains?
Yes, chains like Shake Shack and Dairy Queen offer shakes made with real ice cream or custard nationwide.
Why do some shakes taste thinner or less creamy?
This usually indicates the use of ice cream mix or soft serve instead of real ice cream or custard.
Are premium ice cream shops better for shakes?
Often, yes. Artisanal shops like McConnell’s use high-quality ingredients and small-batch methods that enhance flavor and texture.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a shake made with real ice cream or custard ensures a richer, more authentic dessert experience that’s hard to match with mixes or soft serve alternatives. Whether you prefer the classic diner taste of Steak ’n Shake or the premium quality of McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams, these seven chains stand out by using genuine ice cream ingredients. Next time you crave a shake, opting for one of these chains guarantees a creamy indulgence that’s worth every sip.
Related
- Champions League Prize Money with Performance Bonuses Explained
- Champions League Prize Money and Taxes Explained in Detail
- Full Breakdown of Champions League Prize Money per Round