
This Southern baked macaroni and cheese is a dependable potluck casserole: tender elbow macaroni in a creamy, gently set egg-and-milk custard, with sharp cheddar and a golden layer of cheese on top. It bakes in one dish and needs no separate cheese sauce, so cleanup stays manageable.
Evaporated milk gives the custard a rich texture, while a little dry mustard sharpens the cheese flavor without making the dish taste mustardy. The result is savory, cheesy, and soft in the middle, with browned edges that hold up well on a buffet. Serve it as a side for a crowd or make it the centerpiece of a simple supper.
Why This Recipe Works
The pasta finishes cooking in the oven, so boiling it just shy of al dente helps keep it from turning soft and swollen. Check the package directions and drain the macaroni about two minutes before its suggested cooking time is up. It should still have a slight firmness when bitten.
Instead of making a roux, this recipe uses eggs, evaporated milk, and regular milk to bind the macaroni and cheese. As the casserole bakes, the eggs set into a tender custard. Baking until the center reaches 160°F cooks the egg mixture safely while avoiding an unnecessarily long bake that could dry out the pasta.
Sharp cheddar brings a pronounced cheese flavor, and Monterey Jack melts easily and softens cheddar’s sharper edge. A small amount of dry mustard and black pepper adds depth without competing with the cheese. Mixing some cheese through the pasta and saving some for the top gives you cheese in every serving as well as a browned surface.
There is no stovetop cheese sauce to make or wash up. You will need a pot to cook the pasta, a bowl for the custard, and a 9-by-13-inch baking dish; the casserole itself is mixed and baked in that dish.
Ingredients
- 1 lb elbow macaroni
- 4 qt water, for boiling the pasta
- 1 tbsp kosher salt, for the pasta water
- 1 tbsp butter, softened, for greasing the baking dish
- 2 tbsp unsalted butter, melted
- 3 cups shredded sharp cheddar cheese, divided
- 1 cup shredded Monterey Jack cheese
- 2 large eggs
- 1 can (12 oz) evaporated milk
- 1 cup whole milk
- 1 tsp dry mustard
- ½ tsp black pepper
- ¼ tsp paprika
Ingredient Notes
Elbow macaroni: Its shape catches the custard and cheese, and it is easy to portion at a potluck. Small shells or cavatappi work too; cook any shape just shy of al dente before baking. Avoid very small pasta, which can soften quickly in the oven.
Sharp cheddar: It supplies the main flavor. For the smoothest melt, buy a block and shred it yourself; pre-shredded cheese can still be used, though its coating may make the finished texture slightly less smooth. Mild cheddar is a good substitute if you prefer a gentler flavor.
Monterey Jack: This cheese melts readily and balances the cheddar. Use an equal amount of Colby Jack or mild cheddar if needed. The casserole will be a little sharper if you replace it with extra sharp cheddar.
Evaporated milk and whole milk: Evaporated milk adds body without requiring a separate sauce, while whole milk loosens the mixture enough to coat the pasta. Do not confuse evaporated milk with sweetened condensed milk. If you cannot get evaporated milk, use whole milk in its place; the casserole may set a little more softly.
Eggs: They help the milk mixture set into the classic baked-macaroni custard. Use large eggs as listed, and whisk them thoroughly with the milk so there are no streaks of egg white in the finished casserole.
Dry mustard, pepper, and paprika: Dry mustard makes the cheese taste more rounded; black pepper adds gentle warmth, and paprika gives the top a little color. You can omit the paprika or replace it with a small pinch of cayenne for more heat.
Instructions
- Heat the oven and prepare the dish. Heat the oven to 350°F. Grease a 9-by-13-inch baking dish with the softened butter, coating the bottom and sides. Set the dish near your work area. A greased dish helps the casserole release more cleanly and makes serving easier.
- Boil the macaroni just shy of al dente. Bring 4 qt water to a boil in a large pot, add the kosher salt and macaroni, and cook for about two minutes less than the package’s al dente time. Taste a piece: it should be pliable but still a little firm at the center. The pasta will soften further in the oven. Drain it well; do not rinse, since rinsing removes surface starch that helps the cheese mixture cling.
- Whisk the custard. In a bowl, whisk the eggs until blended, then whisk in the evaporated milk, whole milk, dry mustard, black pepper, and paprika. The mixture should look evenly colored, with no visible strands of egg white. Whisking before it goes into the dish helps the custard bake evenly.
- Combine the pasta and cheese. Put the drained macaroni in the prepared baking dish and pour the melted butter over it. Toss gently to coat. Add 2 cups of the cheddar and all of the Monterey Jack, then stir until the cheese is distributed through the pasta. Keep the remaining 1 cup cheddar for the top; reserving it gives the casserole a distinct cheesy layer.
- Add the milk mixture and top with cheese. Pour the custard evenly over the pasta, nudging the macaroni with a spoon so liquid can run between the pieces. Sprinkle the reserved cheddar over the top. The liquid should be visible around the edges and between the pasta; that is expected and will set as it bakes.
- Bake until set. Bake uncovered for 30 to 35 minutes. Start checking at 30 minutes. The edges should be bubbling gently, the top should be melted with a few golden spots, and the center should no longer look liquid. For a reliable doneness check, insert an instant-read thermometer into the center without touching the bottom of the dish; it should read 160°F. If the center is below that temperature, return the dish to the oven and check again after 3 to 5 minutes.
- Rest before serving. Let the casserole stand for 10 minutes. The custard will finish settling, making it easier to scoop into neat portions. Serve warm, and keep it hot during a buffet rather than leaving it at room temperature for an extended period.
Tips for Success
- Use the pasta timing as a guide, not a guess. Package cooking times vary. Taste a piece before draining; it should still have a little bite because it continues to cook in the oven.
- Drain thoroughly. Excess water left on the pasta can dilute the custard. Give the colander a few shakes, then transfer the macaroni straight to the baking dish.
- Shred cheese from a block when convenient. It melts into the pasta more smoothly than many pre-shredded cheeses. If using packaged shredded cheese, the recipe still works; stir it in evenly.
- Distribute the custard. Pour it around the dish rather than in one spot, then gently shift the pasta with a spoon so there are no dry pockets.
- Watch the center, not just the top. A golden top does not prove the custard has set. Check the middle with a thermometer and take the casserole out when it reaches 160°F.
- Let it rest before scooping. Cutting in immediately can make servings seem loose. Ten minutes gives the custard a chance to settle without cooling the casserole much.
- Plan for the trip. For transport, keep the dish covered and insulated. At the destination, keep hot food at 140°F or above if it will be held for serving.
Troubleshooting
The casserole is dry or crumbly. It may have baked too long, or the pasta may have been cooked fully before baking. Next time, drain the macaroni while it is still slightly firm and begin checking the casserole at 30 minutes. If the top is browning quickly but the center is not yet 160°F, loosely cover the dish with foil and continue baking.
The center is loose after baking. It may need more time, particularly if the pasta or milk mixture went into the dish cold. Check the center temperature and bake in short increments until it reaches 160°F. Rest for 10 minutes before serving; the casserole firms as it stands.
The top browned before the middle set. Loosely tent the dish with foil so the top does not continue to darken, then bake until the center reaches 160°F. Avoid pressing foil onto the cheese, which can stick.
The cheese seems oily. Very high heat or baking well past doneness can cause cheese to separate. Keep the oven at 350°F, use a good melting cheese such as cheddar and Monterey Jack, and remove the casserole once the center is set.
The macaroni is soft. It was likely cooked too long before baking or the casserole stayed in the oven after it was done. Cook the pasta about two minutes shy of its package’s al dente time and check the center temperature rather than relying only on a fixed bake time.
Variations
Add a crunchy top: Toss 1 cup panko breadcrumbs with 1 tbsp melted butter and scatter over the cheese before baking. The crumbs add texture, though the top will be less uniformly cheesy.
Make it gently spicy: Add ¼ tsp cayenne to the custard or use a portion of pepper Jack in place of Monterey Jack. Start modestly, since pepper Jack can vary in heat.
Add pimientos: Fold in ½ cup drained, chopped pimientos with the shredded cheese. Drain them well so their liquid does not thin the custard.
Use another pasta shape: Small shells, cavatappi, or short twists can replace the elbows by weight. Follow the same method and cook the pasta just shy of al dente.
Make a smaller batch: Halve every ingredient and bake in a greased 8-inch-square dish. Begin checking around 25 minutes, but use the center temperature and doneness cues rather than assuming the smaller dish will be ready at an exact time.
What to Serve With It
This rich casserole pairs naturally with dishes that bring freshness, acidity, or a contrasting texture. For a Southern-style potluck plate, serve it alongside collard greens, green beans, braised cabbage, or a crisp vinegar-based slaw. Sliced tomatoes or a simple green salad are useful lighter options.
For a more filling meal, pair it with baked chicken, pulled pork, or barbecue. Add cornbread or biscuits if you want another substantial side, but balance the plate with a vegetable or slaw. Because macaroni and cheese is filling, modest portions leave room for other potluck dishes.
Make-Ahead, Storage and Reheating
Make ahead: For the best texture, cook the pasta and assemble the casserole shortly before baking. You can assemble it, cover it, and refrigerate it for up to 24 hours before baking. Since it will be cold, allow extra baking time and check the center with a thermometer; it must reach 160°F. Do not leave the assembled casserole sitting at room temperature while you prepare other food.
Refrigerate leftovers: Refrigerate leftovers within two hours of serving, or within one hour if the temperature is above 90°F. Store in a covered, shallow container and use within 3 to 4 days. If the casserole has been sitting out past those limits, discard it rather than saving it.
Freeze: For better texture, freeze portions in airtight, freezer-safe containers. Use within 2 to 3 months for best quality. Thaw in the refrigerator before reheating; freezing and thawing can make the pasta softer, but it remains useful for an easy meal. Do not thaw it on the counter.
Reheat: Reheat a portion in the microwave, covered loosely, stirring or turning it partway through if practical. For a larger amount, cover the dish with foil and warm it in a 325°F oven. Add a small splash of milk if the macaroni looks dry. Reheat leftovers to 165°F throughout. If serving from a buffet, keep the casserole at 140°F or hotter; return leftovers to refrigeration within the safe time limits above.
Recipe Card
Servings: 8 to 10 as a side
Prep time: 20 minutes
Cook time: 30 to 35 minutes
Total time: About 1 hour, including a 10-minute rest
Ingredients
- 1 lb elbow macaroni
- 4 qt water
- 1 tbsp kosher salt
- 1 tbsp softened butter, for the baking dish
- 2 tbsp unsalted butter, melted
- 3 cups shredded sharp cheddar cheese, divided
- 1 cup shredded Monterey Jack cheese
- 2 large eggs
- 1 can (12 oz) evaporated milk
- 1 cup whole milk
- 1 tsp dry mustard
- ½ tsp black pepper
- ¼ tsp paprika
Condensed steps
- Heat oven to 350°F and butter a 9-by-13-inch baking dish.
- Boil macaroni in salted water about two minutes shy of al dente; drain well.
- Whisk eggs, evaporated milk, whole milk, mustard, pepper, and paprika.
- Toss macaroni with melted butter, 2 cups cheddar, and all the Monterey Jack in the baking dish.
- Pour the custard evenly over the pasta and top with the remaining 1 cup cheddar.
- Bake uncovered for 30 to 35 minutes, until bubbling and the center reaches 160°F. Rest 10 minutes before serving.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make this without eggs?
The eggs help the milk mixture set into a custard, so leaving them out changes the texture. For an egg-free version, use a recipe designed around a stovetop cheese sauce rather than simply omitting the eggs from this one.
Can I use a different cheese?
Yes. Colby Jack, mild cheddar, or a portion of smoked cheddar can replace some of the listed cheese. Keep the total amount close to 4 cups, and use at least some cheddar or another flavorful cheese so the casserole does not taste bland.
Can I use sweetened condensed milk?
No. Sweetened condensed milk contains added sugar and is not a substitute for evaporated milk here. Use whole milk in its place if evaporated milk is unavailable.
Should I cover the casserole while baking?
Bake it uncovered so the cheese on top can melt and brown. If the top is getting dark before the center reaches 160°F, loosely cover it with foil for the rest of the baking time.
Can I assemble it the night before?
Yes. Cover and refrigerate the assembled casserole for up to 24 hours, then bake until the center reaches 160°F. Expect it to take longer than a casserole that goes into the oven immediately after assembly.
Can I bake it in a disposable foil pan?
Yes, use a sturdy pan of roughly the same size and set it on a baking sheet for support. Thin foil pans can flex when full, so carry the casserole on the sheet rather than lifting the pan by its edges.
How do I keep it warm at a potluck?
Keep it covered and maintain the casserole at 140°F or above while it is being held hot. If you cannot keep it hot, serve it promptly and refrigerate leftovers within the safe time limits in the storage section.
Can I double the recipe?
Yes, double the ingredients and divide the mixture between two 9-by-13-inch dishes rather than putting it all in one deep pan. Two standard-depth casseroles heat more evenly; check each center for 160°F before serving.