If you’re craving an everything bagel in New York City, this list is for you. Whether you’re a local or visiting, these bakeries are known for their outstanding everything bagels—each offering a unique take on the classic blend of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and salt. From traditional Jewish delis to modern artisanal shops, we cover the best places to find a truly memorable everything bagel experience.
Ess-a-Bagel
Ess-a-Bagel, located in Midtown Manhattan, has been a New York staple since 1976. Their everything bagel is thick, chewy, and generously coated with a balanced mix of poppy seeds, sesame seeds, garlic, and onion. Known for their fresh-baked quality and large size, Ess-a-Bagel is a must-visit for anyone serious about authentic New York bagels.
Absolute Bagels
Situated on the Upper West Side, Absolute Bagels offers a perfectly dense and slightly crispy everything bagel that many locals swear by. Their bagels are boiled longer than average, giving them a distinctive crust and a tender interior. The everything seasoning is applied generously, making each bite flavorful without overwhelming the dough.
Russ & Daughters
Russ & Daughters is an iconic appetizing store on the Lower East Side, famous not only for their smoked fish but also for their classic everything bagel. Their bagels are hand-rolled and boiled traditionally, offering a chewy texture that pairs exceptionally well with their signature cream cheese and smoked salmon. The seasoning blend here is finely balanced, enhancing but not overpowering the bagel’s flavor.
Black Seed Bagels
Black Seed Bagels is a newer addition to the New York bagel scene, blending Montreal-style bagel techniques with New York flavors. Their everything bagel is smaller but denser, with a slight sweetness from malt in the dough and a crunchy crust from wood-fired ovens. The seasoning is robust, featuring toasted sesame and poppy seeds, dried garlic, and onion flakes, offering a modern twist on the classic everything bagel.
Murray’s Bagels
Located in Greenwich Village, Murray’s Bagels is famous for its traditional New York bagels, boiled in honey-sweetened water for a slightly sweet crust. Their everything bagel combines a generous amount of classic toppings, including sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, and onion, creating a savory and aromatic bite. Murray’s is a reliable choice for bagel purists looking for consistency and quality.
Tompkins Square Bagels
Tompkins Square Bagels in the East Village offers everything bagels that are hand-rolled and boiled in small batches, ensuring freshness and a soft interior. Their seasoning mix includes toasted sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, and onion, applied thickly to deliver a punch of flavor. Many fans praise Tompkins for its creative spreads and toppings that complement the everything bagel perfectly.
Bagel Hole
Bagel Hole in Park Slope, Brooklyn, is known for its dense, chewy bagels with a slightly crispy crust. Their everything bagel is generously coated with the seasoning blend, and the bagels themselves are smaller and more traditional in size compared to some Manhattan competitors. Bagel Hole’s focus on old-school techniques makes it a favorite among Brooklynites seeking a no-frills, authentic bagel.
Best Bagel and Coffee
Best Bagel and Coffee, located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is a neighborhood favorite offering everything bagels that are boiled and baked fresh daily. Their bagels have a perfect balance of chew and crust, with a well-rounded everything seasoning that highlights the garlic and onion. The shop’s no-nonsense approach and friendly service make it a solid stop for a classic everything bagel.
Leo’s Bagels
Leo’s Bagels, with locations in Brooklyn and Manhattan, delivers everything bagels that are hand-rolled and boiled in water sweetened with barley malt syrup. This process gives their bagels a slightly sweet, chewy texture that contrasts nicely with the savory everything topping. Leo’s is especially praised for its bagels’ consistent quality and the freshness of their toppings.
Tommy’s Bagels
Tommy’s Bagels in Alphabet City is a favorite for those seeking a classic New York everything bagel with a soft, chewy inside and a crisp outside. Their bagels are boiled in honey water and baked fresh throughout the day. The everything seasoning is applied generously, and many customers appreciate the shop’s vintage feel and friendly service, making it a great local spot to enjoy a traditional everything bagel.
How to Choose
When selecting the best everything bagel bakery in New York, consider the bagel’s texture, seasoning balance, and freshness. Traditionalists often prefer bagels that are hand-rolled, boiled in honey or malt water, and have a chewy interior with a slightly crispy crust. The seasoning mix should be generous but not overpowering, balancing sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and salt. Also, think about the bakery’s reputation for freshness and consistency, as a truly great everything bagel tastes best when made daily. Finally, factor in whether you want a classic New York bagel or a modern twist, as some bakeries incorporate unique methods or ingredients.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes an everything bagel different from other bagels?
It’s the seasoning blend—typically sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried garlic, dried onion, and salt—that’s sprinkled on top before baking, giving the bagel a savory, aromatic flavor.
Are everything bagels always boiled before baking?
Yes, traditional New York bagels, including everything bagels, are boiled briefly before baking, which creates their distinctive chewy texture and shiny crust.
Can I find gluten-free everything bagels in New York?
Gluten-free everything bagels are rare at traditional bakeries, but some specialty shops and health-focused bakeries may offer gluten-free versions—though they differ in texture and taste from classic bagels.
Do all everything bagels have the same seasoning mix?
Most use a standard blend, but proportions vary; some bakeries add extra garlic or onion, while others may include additional seeds or salt for a unique flavor.
Is it better to eat everything bagels fresh or toasted?
Fresh everything bagels offer the best chew and flavor, but toasting can enhance the seasoning’s crunch and deepen the bagel’s aroma, depending on personal preference.
Where can I get the best everything bagel cream cheese pairing?
Many New York bakeries, like Russ & Daughters and Tompkins Square Bagels, offer house-made cream cheeses with flavors that complement the everything bagel, such as scallion, chive, or smoked salmon spreads.
Final Thoughts
New York’s everything bagel scene is rich and varied, with options ranging from time-honored delis to innovative artisanal bakeries. Whether you prefer a dense, chewy bagel with a subtle seasoning or a crunchy, boldly flavored everything bagel, these bakeries offer something for every palate. Exploring these spots not only satisfies your bagel craving but also connects you to a beloved culinary tradition that defines New York City’s food culture. Next time you’re in the city, make it a point to try a few of these top everything bagel bakeries to discover your personal favorite.
Related
- Kale Salad with Parmesan Cheese: 10 Delicious Variations to Try
- Peach Upside Down Chocolate Pudding Recipes and Tips You’ll Love
- How to Make a Good Kale Salad: Easy Steps for a Delicious Dish