If you love the classic Reuben sandwich but want a lighter, poultry-based twist, grilled turkey Reuben sandwiches are a delicious option. This list covers some of the best ways to enjoy this savory sandwich, perfect for home cooks, sandwich aficionados, and anyone looking to elevate their lunch game with a smoky, tangy, and melty meal.
1. Classic Grilled Turkey Reuben with Sauerkraut and Swiss
This version stays true to the traditional Reuben but swaps corned beef for thinly sliced roasted turkey breast. The sandwich layers Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on rye bread, then grills it to crispy perfection. The turkey adds a leaner protein without sacrificing the sandwich’s signature flavors.
2. Smoked Turkey Reuben with Thousand Island Dressing
Using smoked turkey breast introduces a subtle smoky flavor that complements the creamy Thousand Island dressing. This combination pairs well with melted Swiss cheese and sauerkraut, all grilled between slices of marble rye for a visually appealing and flavorful bite.
3. Turkey Pastrami Reuben with Pickles
Turkey pastrami, seasoned with traditional pastrami spices, adds a robust and peppery kick to the sandwich. Incorporating crunchy dill pickles alongside sauerkraut enhances the tang factor, while Swiss cheese melted on toasted rye bread rounds out the rich, savory profile.
4. Open-Faced Grilled Turkey Reuben Melt
For a lighter presentation, the open-faced melt uses one slice of rye bread topped with turkey, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing, then broiled until bubbly and golden. This version reduces bread carbs while still delivering the classic Reuben taste and gooey texture.
5. Grilled Turkey Reuben with Homemade Russian Dressing
Making your own Russian dressing from mayonnaise, ketchup, horseradish, Worcestershire sauce, and paprika can elevate the sandwich’s flavor complexity. Using freshly sliced turkey breast and tangy sauerkraut on rye bread, grilled until the cheese melts, creates a standout sandwich experience.
6. Turkey Reuben Wrap with Coleslaw
For a portable twist, the turkey Reuben wrap replaces bread with a large flour tortilla, wrapping smoked turkey, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and coleslaw tossed in Russian dressing. Grilling the wrap on a panini press melts the cheese and crisps the tortilla while keeping the fillings warm and flavorful.
7. Grilled Turkey Reuben with Swiss and Caraway Rye
Choosing caraway rye bread adds an aromatic, slightly sweet note that complements the Swiss cheese and turkey. Layered with sauerkraut and Russian dressing, then grilled to a golden crisp, this sandwich offers a nuanced flavor profile that highlights the bread’s distinctive seeds.
8. Spicy Chipotle Turkey Reuben
Adding chipotle mayonnaise in place of traditional Russian or Thousand Island dressing gives this sandwich a smoky heat. Paired with roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, and sauerkraut on rye bread, the chipotle kick adds depth and a pleasant warmth without overpowering the other ingredients.
9. Vegan Turkey Reuben with Plant-Based Deli Slices
For those who prefer plant-based options, vegan deli slices made from seitan or soy can substitute turkey. Combined with vegan Swiss-style cheese, sauerkraut, and a vegan Russian dressing on rye bread, then grilled to melt the cheese substitute, this sandwich satisfies the craving with no animal products.
10. Turkey Reuben with Caramelized Onions and Gruyère
Replacing Swiss cheese with Gruyère adds a nutty, slightly sweet complexity to the sandwich. Caramelized onions lend extra depth and sweetness that balance the tangy sauerkraut and savory turkey. This gourmet take on the Reuben is grilled on rye for a flavorful upgrade.
How to Choose
When selecting your grilled turkey Reuben sandwich style, consider the type of turkey—smoked, roasted, or pastrami-style—as it strongly influences the flavor. The bread choice is equally important; traditional rye offers authenticity, while caraway rye adds aromatic notes. Decide on the cheese, with Swiss being classic, but Gruyère or vegan alternatives available for variation. Dressing selection, whether Russian, Thousand Island, or spicy chipotle, will affect the sandwich’s tang and heat levels. Finally, think about add-ons like caramelized onions or pickles to enhance complexity. Your choice depends on whether you want a classic taste, a smoky twist, or a gourmet experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use leftover turkey for grilled turkey Reuben sandwiches?
Yes, leftover turkey works well, especially if sliced thinly. Just ensure it’s reheated properly when grilling to maintain moisture and flavor.
What is the best bread for a turkey Reuben?
Traditional rye bread is preferred for its hearty texture and slightly sour flavor, but marble rye or caraway rye can add interesting twists.
Is Russian dressing the same as Thousand Island?
Russian dressing typically contains mayonnaise, ketchup, horseradish, and spices, while Thousand Island includes finely chopped pickles and sometimes hard-boiled eggs, making it sweeter and chunkier.
How do I prevent the sandwich from becoming soggy?
Pat sauerkraut dry before assembling and grill the sandwich on medium heat to crisp the bread quickly. Using a panini press or weighted skillet helps create a sealed, crispy exterior.
Can I make a turkey Reuben sandwich gluten-free?
Yes, substitute rye bread with gluten-free bread varieties and ensure all other ingredients, especially dressings and deli meats, are gluten-free certified.
What is the USDA safe temperature for cooking turkey in sandwiches?
Turkey should reach an internal temperature of 165°F (74°C) for safety. When reheating or grilling, ensure the turkey is heated through to this temperature.
Final Thoughts
Grilled turkey Reuben sandwiches offer a versatile and flavorful alternative to the traditional corned beef version, appealing to those seeking a leaner protein or different taste profiles. Whether you prefer classic rye with Swiss and Russian dressing or a smoky chipotle twist, the key to a great sandwich lies in quality ingredients and proper grilling technique. Experimenting with bread types, cheeses, and dressings can help you find your perfect grilled turkey Reuben that satisfies cravings while keeping lunch exciting.
Related
- Fried Rice Recipe with Jasmine Rice: Easy, Flavorful & Authentic
- Fried Rice with Day Old Rice: 7 Tips for Perfect Results
- Fried Pickle Ranch Dip Recipes and Tips You Need to Try