
Homemade cinnamon ornaments are cut-out decorations made from a firm dough of ground cinnamon, unsweetened applesauce, and white school glue. Roll it, stamp it with cookie cutters, make a hole for hanging, then dry the shapes until firm. They’re a hands-on holiday craft, not a snack: the glue makes them inedible, so don’t taste the dough or finished ornaments.
This version uses equal parts cinnamon, applesauce, and glue for a dough that rolls and holds its shape when the moisture is managed carefully. The ornaments aren’t meant to taste like anything; while you work, the mixture has a strong cinnamon scent, but it is not food. A low oven helps dry the cutouts through, and turning them during baking helps limit curling.
Why This Recipe Works
Each ingredient has a practical job. Cinnamon supplies the bulk and the familiar color and scent. Applesauce adds moisture so the powder can come together into a workable dough. White school glue binds the mixture and helps the dried shapes hold together. The dough should feel like soft clay rather than wet batter: firm enough to cut cleanly, but not so dry that it cracks as you roll it.
Mixing the wet ingredients into the cinnamon gradually gives you a chance to judge the texture before the dough becomes overly sticky. A short rest after mixing also gives dry cinnamon time to absorb moisture. Rolling between sheets of parchment or wax paper limits sticking without adding much extra cinnamon to the dough. Finally, making the hanging holes before drying avoids cracking a brittle ornament afterward.
Slow, gentle drying matters more than browning. A low oven removes moisture without trying to bake the ornaments like cookies. Turning them partway through exposes both faces to the warm air and helps the pieces dry more evenly. They should be firm and dry to the touch when done; the center should not feel cool or soft.
Ingredients
- 1 cup ground cinnamon
- 1 cup unsweetened applesauce
- 1 cup white school glue
- 1 mixing bowl
- 1 wooden spoon or spatula
- 1 rolling pin
- 1 sheet parchment paper or wax paper, large enough to cover the work surface
- 1 set of cookie cutters in assorted shapes
- 1 drinking straw
- 1 yard ribbon or twine for hanging
Ingredient Notes
Ground cinnamon: Use ordinary finely ground cinnamon, not cinnamon sticks or a coarse spice blend. It forms most of the dough and gives the ornaments their color and scent. A different ground baking spice can change the scent and color, but cinnamon gives the most recognizable result. Avoid adding a large amount of extra cinnamon just to hide stickiness; too much can make the dough crumbly.
Unsweetened applesauce: Applesauce brings water and helps the dry cinnamon combine. Unsweetened is a straightforward choice because added sugar is unnecessary for a craft dough. Smooth applesauce is easiest to mix. If yours is especially watery, spoon it in gradually and stop once the dough is pliable; if the dough is too dry, add a little more applesauce by the teaspoon.
White school glue: Glue is the binder that helps a dry ornament keep its shape. Use ordinary white school glue rather than a glue stick, paste, or hot glue, which will not mix into the dough in the same way. Glue can irritate some skin, so wash your hands after handling the mixture and follow the label. The dough and ornaments are not edible, even if the glue is labeled non-toxic.
Paper, cutters, straw, and hanging material: Parchment is convenient for rolling and transferring shapes; wax paper also works as a work surface, but do not put wax paper in the oven. Cutters with simple outlines release more easily than very intricate shapes. A drinking straw makes a clean hanging hole. Choose ribbon or twine that fits through the hole after the ornament has dried.
Instructions
- Prepare the drying setup. Heat the oven to 200°F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper; do not use wax paper in the oven. Keep the sheet and finished ornaments separate from food, and set out the straw and cutters before mixing. The oven should feel gently warm rather than hot, because a high temperature can darken the edges before the centers dry.
- Combine the dough. Put the cinnamon in the mixing bowl. Add the applesauce and glue, then stir with the wooden spoon or spatula until the mixture looks evenly damp and no dry pockets remain, about 2 to 3 minutes. Scrape the bowl as you mix. The dough is ready to knead when it gathers into a mass rather than flowing like a paste; this helps the ornaments keep crisp outlines.
- Knead and assess. Knead the mixture in the bowl or on parchment for 1 to 2 minutes, pressing and folding until it feels like soft, smooth clay. If it sticks heavily to your fingers, work in a little cinnamon, about 1 tablespoon at a time. If it breaks at the edges when pressed, work in applesauce, about 1 teaspoon at a time. Stop adjusting when it can be pressed into a ball without leaving a wet smear.
- Let the dough rest. Cover the dough and leave it at room temperature for 10 minutes. This brief pause lets the cinnamon take up some of the moisture and makes the dough easier to roll. After resting, press a fingertip into it: it should be supple, not glossy or sticky. If it has firmed a little, knead it briefly before rolling.
- Roll it evenly. Place the dough between sheets of parchment or wax paper and roll it to about ¼ inch thick. Turn or reposition the paper as needed so the sheet stays even. A uniform thickness is important: thin points dry and become fragile before thicker areas are done. Peel back the top sheet slowly; if the dough clings, replace it and chill the covered dough for 10 minutes before trying again.
- Cut and make the holes. Press the cutters straight down, then lift them without twisting so the outlines stay neat. Remove the surrounding scraps and reroll them gently. Use the straw to make a hole near the top of each shape, leaving enough dough between the hole and the edge to support the ribbon. Check that each hole goes all the way through and clear away the little dough plug. This is easier now than after drying.
- Arrange the ornaments. Transfer the shapes to the lined baking sheet with a little space between them. If a shape stretches while you move it, nudge it back into place with your fingertips. Smooth obvious cracks with a lightly damp fingertip, but avoid wetting the whole surface. Keeping the shapes flat and intact now helps them dry without distorted edges.
- Dry in the oven. Bake at 200°F for 2 to 3 hours, turning the ornaments over after about 1 hour. Begin checking the smaller or thinner pieces first. They are ready when both sides feel dry and firm, the edges have not browned, and the center is not soft or cool to the touch. If a thick ornament still bends or feels damp, continue drying in 15-minute increments. Oven behavior and ornament thickness vary, so use the texture cues rather than relying only on the clock.
- Cool completely and add the hanging loop. Move the sheet to a heat-safe surface and let the ornaments cool completely before threading ribbon or twine through the holes. Cooling lets the shapes finish firming and makes them less likely to bend during handling. Tie a knot or a small loop, then store or hang them only when they are fully dry.
Yield: about a dozen or more ornaments, depending on cutter size. Prep time: about 30 minutes. Cook time: 2 to 3 hours. Total time: about 3 to 4 hours, including cooling.
Tips for Success
- Adjust texture in small increments. Applesauce moisture and cinnamon grind can vary. Add cinnamon or applesauce a spoonful at a time, kneading between additions. A small correction is easier to manage than a large one.
- Keep the rolling thickness consistent. Aim for roughly ¼ inch throughout. If one side is much thicker, the thin side can become brittle while the thick side is still damp.
- Choose simple cutter shapes for the first batch. Broad outlines and rounded edges are easier to lift from the paper and less likely to snap at narrow points.
- Make generous hanging holes. The hole can shrink slightly as the dough dries. Leave a sturdy bridge of dough between the hole and the top edge, and make the opening wide enough for the ribbon or twine you plan to use.
- Turn the ornaments carefully. Use a thin spatula once they feel dry enough to lift without bending. If they are still soft, give them more time before turning rather than forcing them off the sheet.
- Dry by feel as well as by time. A damp center can be hard to see from the outside. Check the thickest ornament, not just the smallest one, before ending the drying period.
- Keep them away from children and pets while they dry. These are decorations, not treats. Label or store them separately from food crafts so nobody mistakes them for something edible.
Troubleshooting
The dough is sticky and smears on the paper. Knead in ground cinnamon a little at a time, then let the dough rest briefly. If the room is warm or the applesauce was loose, chilling the covered dough for 10 minutes can make it easier to handle. Avoid dusting heavily with extra cinnamon, which can leave dry patches and make cut edges crumble.
The dough cracks while rolling. It is probably too dry or was rolled too thin. Knead in applesauce by the teaspoon until the surface becomes pliable, then roll between paper again. Press cracks together with your fingertips before cutting; once the shapes dry, those seams can become weak points.
The cutters drag or the shapes distort. The dough may be too soft, or the cutter may have a detailed outline. Chill the covered dough briefly, press the cutter straight down, and lift it vertically without twisting. A thin spatula can help transfer larger shapes.
The ornaments curl or puff unevenly. Check that the dough was rolled evenly and turn the pieces during drying. Lower the oven temperature if edges are darkening before the center is dry. A little variation in shape is normal, but pronounced curling usually means uneven thickness or uneven drying.
The center is still soft after the edges feel firm. Continue drying at 200°F in short increments, checking the thickest piece each time. Do not raise the heat to hurry the process; the exterior can over-dry while moisture remains inside.
A shape breaks or a hole closes up. If the dough is still damp, press the crack together or reopen the hole gently with the straw. If the ornament has fully dried, do not force the straw through it; that can split the shape. Use a smaller ribbon if it fits, or keep the piece as a flat decoration.
Variations
Change the shapes. Use stars, trees, hearts, or simple circles, or cut a few different sizes from the same sheet. Keep narrow tips and delicate bridges to a minimum if the ornaments will be handled often. Pressing a shallow design into the dough with a clean stamp or the blunt end of a utensil can add texture without cutting all the way through.
Add a simple surface detail. Once the ornaments are completely dry, decorate them with craft paint or a paint pen, following the product label. Let any decoration dry fully before storing. Keep paint and other craft materials away from food and from the ribbon holes so the hanging loop can still pass through.
Make gift tags or garland pieces. Cut smaller shapes and make the hanging hole before drying. For a garland, thread the finished pieces with space between them so they do not rub together. Use a short length of ribbon for individual gifts, or longer twine for a strand of decorations.
Try different outlines in one batch. A mix of cutters makes a coordinated set without changing the dough. Similar thicknesses dry at a more similar pace; remove small pieces as they become firm and leave thicker ones in the oven longer.
What to Serve With It
These ornaments are not served as food. Use them as tree decorations, gift toppers, place-setting accents, or pieces in a seasonal garland. Pair the craft with a separate snack or drink if you are making ornaments with family, and keep edible treats on a different tray and work surface. Don’t put the ornaments on food, use them as cake decorations, or allow anyone to chew them.
For a finished display, tie each ornament with ribbon or twine once it has cooled and dried completely. They also work well attached to wrapped gifts, provided the recipient knows they are decorative. If you plan to hang them near a candle, heater, or other heat source, choose another spot; these are dried craft materials, not heat-resistant decorations.
Make-Ahead, Storage and Reheating
The dough is easiest to use fresh, but it can be covered and refrigerated promptly if you need to pause. Keep it in a sealed container at 40°F or colder and use it within 3 to 4 days. This is a conservative storage window for a perishable mixture, not a reason to taste it: the dough contains glue and must never be eaten. Discard it if it has been left out for an extended period or shows an unexpected change in smell or appearance.
Freezing the unshaped dough is not ideal because thawing may change its texture and make it harder to roll. If you choose to freeze it, seal it well, thaw it in the refrigerator, and knead it before shaping; discard it if the texture or appearance is concerning. Do not thaw it on the counter for a long stretch. The ornaments themselves do not need refrigeration once fully dry. Store them in a cool, dry place in a sturdy box, with paper between layers to reduce scuffs and breakage.
There is no reheating step for finished ornaments. If they soften after storage, do not microwave them or warm them near a flame. Let them air-dry in a dry room, or return them to a low oven at 200°F for 15-minute intervals, checking that they do not darken. Replace any ornament that becomes moldy, soft, or badly cracked, and keep finished pieces away from food.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are cinnamon ornaments edible?
No. The white glue makes this a craft dough, even if the glue is labeled non-toxic. Do not taste the mixture or finished ornaments, and keep them away from food and from children or pets who might chew them.
Can I make them without glue?
This recipe relies on glue to bind the cinnamon and help the dried shapes hold together. Leaving it out changes the dough and can make ornaments more fragile. Use a recipe specifically formulated without glue if you need a glue-free craft; don’t assume the same proportions will work.
Can I air-dry the ornaments instead of using the oven?
Yes. Arrange them on a clean, dry surface with airflow and turn them occasionally. Air-drying takes longer and depends on room humidity and thickness, so check that the centers are fully firm and dry before storing. Keep them away from food while they dry.
Why did my ornaments turn darker?
Some color variation is expected from the cinnamon, but browning can mean the oven was too hot or the pieces were left in too long. Use a low temperature, check early, and rely on firmness rather than waiting for a toasted color. A darker ornament is still a decoration, but it may have a more brittle surface.
How do I keep the hole from closing?
Make the opening fully through the dough with a straw before drying, and clear out the small plug. If it narrows while the ornament is still damp, gently reopen it. Once fully dry, forcing a tool through may crack the ornament.
Can I paint the ornaments?
Yes, after they are completely dry and cool. Use craft paint or a paint pen according to its label, and let the finish dry before handling or storing. Keep paint away from food-contact surfaces and remember that painted ornaments remain inedible.
How can I tell when they are completely dry?
They should feel firm on both faces, with no soft or cool-feeling center. Check a thicker piece rather than judging only by the smaller cutouts. If you are unsure, continue drying gently or let the ornaments air-dry longer before putting them away.
