Mets Minor League Blog

Music theory, instruments and musicians

Mets Minor League Blog

Music theory, instruments and musicians

Homemade Old Fashioned Cherry Pie Recipe

Homemade Old Fashioned Cherry Pie Recipe

This homemade old fashioned cherry pie has a buttery, flaky top and bottom crust wrapped around sweet-tart cherries scented with vanilla and a little almond. It uses fresh or frozen pitted cherries, so you can make it without waiting for cherry season.

A measured amount of cornstarch thickens the fruit juices, while lemon juice keeps the filling bright rather than cloying. The recipe makes a deliberately modest, shallow pie for an 8-inch pie plate; after baking, let it cool completely so the filling can set into neat slices.

Why This Recipe Works

Cherries release juice as they heat. Tossing them with sugar, cornstarch, lemon, and salt before they go into the crust spreads the thickener evenly, reducing the chance of a pocket of watery filling or a mouthful of starch. The cornstarch thickens as the filling reaches a full simmer in the oven, so look for bubbles in the center, not just around the edges.

A hot start helps the bottom crust begin baking before the filling has time to soak into it. Lowering the oven temperature after the first 15 minutes gives the fruit time to cook through without overbrowning the pastry. Finally, cooling is part of the recipe, not an optional pause: the filling is loose when hot and firms as it cools.

Two cups of cherries make a lower-profile pie than many full-size cherry pie recipes. An 8-inch plate suits the amount well. If using a standard 9-inch plate, expect a shallower filling and take care not to stretch the crust thin over the wider dish.

Ingredients

  • 2 cups pitted fresh or frozen cherries
  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 2 tablespoons cornstarch
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1/4 teaspoon almond extract, optional but recommended
  • 1/4 teaspoon fine salt
  • 1 tablespoon butter, cut into small pieces
  • 2 pie crusts, homemade or store-bought, sized for an 8-inch pie plate

Ingredient Notes

Cherries: Sweet cherries make a mellow filling; sour cherries make it sharper. Either works, but the final sweetness will vary with the fruit. Measure cherries after pitting. If starting with frozen cherries, thaw them and drain off the pooled liquid before measuring. This keeps excess thawing liquid from making the filling loose.

Sugar: Granulated sugar sweetens the fruit and helps draw out its juices. Because cherries vary, taste one before mixing. The stated amount gives a distinctly sweet pie; avoid cutting it sharply, since sugar also contributes to the filling’s texture.

Cornstarch: This is the thickener. Stir it thoroughly into the sugar before adding the fruit so it disperses without lumps. Arrowroot can be substituted in a similar amount, though it may produce a slightly different, glossier filling. Flour is less reliable here and can leave the filling cloudy or pasty.

Lemon, vanilla, and almond: Lemon juice balances the sugar and gives the cherries a fresher flavor. Vanilla rounds out the fruit. Almond extract is optional, but its flavor pairs naturally with cherries; measure carefully, as a little goes a long way. If you do not have it, simply leave it out.

Salt and butter: Salt sharpens the overall flavor. Unsalted butter is easiest to control; if using salted butter, the small amount here is still fine. Butter pieces scattered over the filling add richness as they melt.

Pie crust: Use two crusts, one for the base and one for the top. Keep the dough cold and handle it as little as possible. Homemade or store-bought crusts both work; follow package directions for thawing a refrigerated or frozen crust, but do not pre-bake it for this recipe.

Instructions

  1. Prepare the oven and plate. Set a rack in the lower third of the oven and heat to 425°F. Place a rimmed baking sheet on the rack to preheat; it will catch drips and help the base crust start baking promptly. Have an 8-inch pie plate ready.
  2. Mix the filling. In a large bowl, whisk together the sugar, cornstarch, and salt. Add the pitted cherries, lemon juice, vanilla, and almond extract, then fold until the cherries are evenly coated and no dry cornstarch remains. The mixture may look a little powdery at first, then turn glossy as the fruit releases juice. If using thawed frozen cherries, drain the pooled liquid first.
  3. Line the pie plate. Roll or unroll one cold crust and fit it into the plate, easing it into the corners without pulling or stretching it. Leave about 1/2 inch of overhang. A relaxed crust is less likely to shrink while baking.
  4. Fill and add butter. Spoon the cherry mixture into the lined crust, scraping in the sugar and juices from the bowl. Spread the cherries into an even layer and dot the top with the small pieces of butter. Even distribution helps the filling cook consistently.
  5. Add the top crust. Lay the second crust over the fruit. Trim both crusts to leave roughly 1/2 inch beyond the rim, tuck the edges under together, and crimp firmly. Cut several slits in the top, or make a lattice, so steam can escape. The vents should be open rather than sealed by dough.
  6. Bake hot, then lower the heat. Set the pie on the preheated baking sheet. Bake at 425°F for 15 minutes, until the pastry edges look set and the crust is beginning to color. Reduce the oven to 375°F without removing the pie and continue baking for about 35–45 minutes. If the rim is browning too quickly, cover just the edge loosely with foil.
  7. Check for a properly cooked filling. The pie is ready when the top crust is golden and thick, active bubbles appear through the center vents, and the filling is visibly bubbling near the middle. Bubbles only at the edge are not enough for the cornstarch to thicken the whole filling. Add 5-minute increments if needed, watching the crust.
  8. Cool completely before slicing. Transfer the pie to a rack and cool for at least 3 hours. The filling will look loose if cut hot; cooling lets the thickener set. For the cleanest slices, cool it longer or refrigerate it after it has stopped steaming.

Tips for Success

  • Keep the pastry cold. If the assembled pie feels soft or greasy, chill it for 15–20 minutes before baking. Cold dough is easier to handle and is less likely to lose its shape in the oven.
  • Use a rimmed baking sheet. Cherry juices can bubble over, especially if the pie is filled generously. The sheet catches drips and saves the oven floor from burnt sugar.
  • Do not skip the center-bubble cue. A golden crust can be ready before the center filling has simmered enough to thicken. Look through the vents for bubbles in the middle.
  • Shield only what is browning. If the rim darkens before the filling bubbles, cover the edge with a strip of foil. If the whole top is getting too dark, tent it loosely without pressing foil against the crust.
  • Let the pie cool on a rack. Air circulating under the plate limits condensation and helps the base stay crisper. Avoid slicing while the filling is hot.
  • Adjust expectations for the fruit. Very juicy cherries can make a softer filling. Draining thawed fruit and baking until the center bubbles are the two most useful safeguards.

Troubleshooting

The filling is runny. The pie may have been cut before it cooled, or the center may not have bubbled long enough. Let it cool fully before judging the set. If it is already sliced, chill the pieces; they will firm somewhat, though the slices may remain soft. Next time, drain thawed cherries well and bake until bubbles show in the center.

The bottom crust is soggy. A wet filling, a cool oven, or a pie cut while hot can contribute. Use the lower oven rack and preheated baking sheet, and make sure the oven is fully at temperature before baking. Cooling on a rack also helps. Do not add extra liquid to frozen cherries.

The crust is browning before the filling is done. Cover the rim or top loosely with foil and continue baking until the center filling bubbles. Do not take the pie out just because the crust has reached the color you want; the fruit needs to cook through.

Juice leaks onto the baking sheet. A little bubbling over is harmless. Crimp the edges firmly, leave enough overhang to tuck the two crusts together, and avoid overfilling. Bake on a rimmed sheet for easy cleanup.

The filling tastes too sweet or too tart. The variety and ripeness of the cherries make a real difference. For a future pie, taste the fruit first and adjust the sugar modestly. Keep the cornstarch and lemon in proportion so the filling still thickens and tastes balanced.

Variations

Make a lattice top: Cut the top crust into strips and weave them over the filling, leaving open spaces for steam to escape. A lattice also makes it easier to see when the fruit is bubbling.

Use only one kind of extract: For a straightforward cherry flavor, omit the almond extract and use the vanilla alone. If you enjoy the almond note, keep to the small measured amount; too much can overwhelm the cherries.

Try a different cherry balance: A mix of sweet and sour cherries gives a more complex sweet-tart filling. Use the same total of 2 cups, and remember that a batch with more sour cherries may taste less sweet.

Make hand pies instead: Cut pastry into smaller rounds, add a modest spoonful of filling, seal the edges well, and vent the tops. Baking time will be shorter and depends on size, so bake until the pastry is golden and the filling bubbles at the vents.

What to Serve With It

Serve slices plain if you want the cherry and pastry flavors to lead. A spoonful of softly whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream is a classic pairing, particularly while the pie is just slightly warm. Keep accompaniments simple; the almond and vanilla in the filling already add fragrance.

This pie also works well as a make-ahead dessert. If serving it warm, reheat individual slices gently rather than warming the whole pie repeatedly. For a neat presentation, let the pie cool fully and cut with a sharp knife, wiping the blade between slices.

Make-Ahead, Storage and Reheating

Make ahead: You can prepare the pie a day before serving and keep it covered in the refrigerator after it has cooled. You can also mix the dry sugar, cornstarch, and salt ahead, but combine them with the cherries shortly before assembling so the fruit does not sit and release juice for a long time.

Refrigerate: For conservative food handling, refrigerate the cooled pie within 2 hours of baking. Cover it and keep it refrigerated for 3–4 days. A chilled pie is firmer and easier to slice; bring a slice toward room temperature if you prefer a softer filling.

Freeze: For best quality, freeze the baked pie, cooled completely and wrapped airtight, for about 2–3 months. Thaw it overnight in the refrigerator. The crust may be a little less crisp after freezing, but the filling remains suitable for serving. You can also freeze individual slices, wrapped separately.

Reheat: Warm a slice in a 325°F oven until heated through; the time depends on the slice and whether it starts cold. USDA guidance for reheated leftovers is to reach 165°F. Check the filling with a food thermometer if you need to verify the temperature. A pie slice can also be eaten chilled without reheating.

Recipe Card

Servings: 6–8 slices
Prep time: 25 minutes
Cook time: 50–60 minutes
Cooling time: At least 3 hours
Total time: About 4 hours 20 minutes, plus any extra cooling

Ingredients

  • 2 cups pitted fresh or frozen cherries
  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 2 tablespoons cornstarch
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1/4 teaspoon almond extract, optional but recommended
  • 1/4 teaspoon fine salt
  • 1 tablespoon butter, cut into small pieces
  • 2 pie crusts, homemade or store-bought, for an 8-inch pie plate

Condensed Instructions

  1. Heat the oven to 425°F with a rimmed baking sheet on a lower rack.
  2. Whisk sugar, cornstarch, and salt. Fold in cherries, lemon juice, vanilla, and almond extract until coated.
  3. Fit one crust into an 8-inch pie plate, leaving about 1/2 inch overhang. Add the filling and dot with butter.
  4. Top with the second crust, seal and crimp the edges, then cut vents or make a lattice.
  5. Bake on the hot sheet for 15 minutes at 425°F. Reduce to 375°F and bake 35–45 minutes more, until golden and bubbling in the center. Shield browning crust with foil.
  6. Cool on a rack for at least 3 hours before slicing so the filling can set.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use frozen cherries without thawing them?

Thaw them first, then drain the pooled liquid before measuring the 2 cups. Frozen fruit can release extra water as it bakes, and draining that liquid helps the filling thicken as intended. Do not squeeze the cherries dry.

Do I need to cook the cherry filling before putting it in the crust?

No. Mix the ingredients and add the filling directly to the unbaked crust. The oven cooks the fruit and activates the cornstarch. The important cue is bubbling in the center of the pie before you take it out.

Can I use a 9-inch pie plate?

Yes, but the pie will be shallower because the recipe contains 2 cups of cherries. Keep the crust edges secure and begin checking for doneness at the early end of the time range. An 8-inch plate gives the filling more depth.

Why does the pie need to cool for so long?

The filling is hot and fluid when it comes out of the oven. As it cools, the cornstarch-thickened juices settle and hold together. Cutting too soon can make even a properly baked pie seem runny.

How can I tell when the pie is done?

The crust should be golden, and the filling should bubble through the center vents as well as near the edges. If the crust is browning but the middle is not bubbling, cover the crust loosely with foil and continue baking.

Can I make this pie without almond extract?

Yes. Almond extract is optional; leaving it out gives you a clean cherry, lemon, and vanilla flavor. Do not replace it with extra vanilla unless you specifically want a stronger vanilla note.

Can I freeze the pie before baking?

You can assemble and freeze it, tightly wrapped, but the fruit may release extra liquid as it thaws and bakes. For a more predictable filling, bake the pie first, cool it completely, then wrap and freeze. Thaw baked pie in the refrigerator before serving or reheating.

Can I make this recipe with a lattice crust?

Yes. A lattice top works well and provides plenty of openings for steam to escape. Keep the strips chilled while weaving, crimp the lattice securely to the bottom crust, and use the same baking temperatures and bubbling cue.

Homemade Old Fashioned Cherry Pie Recipe
Scroll to top