No, borscht is not inherently a cold soup—it is a family of soups, and while some versions are served chilled, the most iconic and widely eaten borscht is served hot. The word “borscht” refers to a sour soup of Eastern European origin, most commonly associated with Ukraine, where the hot beet-and-cabbage version is considered a national dish. Cold borscht, often called “holodnik” or “šaltibarščiai,” is a distinct regional variation, usually made with raw or lightly cooked beets, kefir or sour cream, and fresh herbs, and it is especially popular in Lithuania, Poland, and Russia during summer.
What Exactly Is Borscht?
Borscht is a soup whose defining characteristic is its sour flavor, traditionally achieved with fermented beet juice (called kvas in Russian and sok z buraków in Polish) or, more commonly today, with vinegar, lemon juice, or tomatoes. The base is almost always beets, though in some regions (like Poland’s barszcz biały) the sourness comes from fermented rye flour and the beets are omitted entirely.
The classic hot Ukrainian borscht includes beef or pork bones, cabbage, potatoes, carrots, onions, and a generous amount of beets, which give it a deep red color. It is typically served with a dollop of sour cream (smetana) and fresh dill, often accompanied by garlicky pampushky (yeast rolls). This hot version is a hearty, warming meal, especially in cold weather.
The Cold Borscht Family
Cold borscht is not a modern invention—it has been part of Eastern European cuisine for centuries, but it is a separate dish from the hot soup. The most common cold version is holodnik (from the Russian word for “cold”), which is popular in Lithuania, Poland, and Belarus. It is made by blending cooked or raw grated beets with kefir, buttermilk, or sour cream, then thinning it with water or beet broth. It is served chilled, often with hard-boiled eggs, cucumbers, radishes, and fresh dill, and sometimes with boiled potatoes on the side.
In Lithuania, this cold soup is called šaltibarščiai and is a national summer staple, often bright pink and served with hot boiled potatoes. In Poland, chłodnik is a similar chilled beet soup, sometimes made with a base of young beet leaves and cucumbers. These cold versions are refreshing and light, quite different from the rich, meaty hot borscht.
Regional Differences: Hot vs. Cold
The hot and cold versions are not just temperature variations—they are built on different ingredients and techniques. Here’s a quick comparison:
- Hot borscht (Ukraine, Russia, Poland): cooked with meat or bone broth, cabbage, potatoes, and beets; served warm, often with sour cream and dark rye bread.
- Cold borscht (Lithuania, Poland, Russia): no meat, no broth; base is fermented or cooked beets mixed with dairy (kefir, sour cream, or yogurt); served chilled, garnished with eggs and fresh vegetables.
- White borscht (Poland): a hot soup made with fermented rye flour, sausage, and hard-boiled eggs, but no beets—shows that the “borscht” name is broader than just beet soup.
So when someone asks “Is borscht a cold soup?” the accurate answer is: it depends on which borscht you mean. The hot version is the default in most of the world, but the cold version is equally authentic in its own right.
How to Serve and Eat Borscht
If you’re making hot borscht, it’s traditionally served as a main course, with a spoonful of sour cream stirred in just before eating. The soup is often accompanied by dark rye bread or garlic pampushky. Cold borscht, on the other hand, is a summer refresher, served as a starter or light lunch, with a halved hard-boiled egg floating on top and a side of boiled potatoes (in Lithuania, the potatoes are served hot, creating a pleasant contrast).
Both versions benefit from a day of rest in the refrigerator—the flavors meld and deepen overnight. Hot borscht can be reheated gently, but cold borscht should be kept chilled and stirred before serving.
Common Misconceptions
One common myth is that borscht must always contain beets. While beets are the most recognizable ingredient, some regional versions (like Polish white borscht) use no beets at all. Another misconception is that cold borscht is just leftover hot borscht served chilled—that’s not true; cold borscht is made with a dairy base and no meat, so it’s a completely different recipe.
Also, some people assume that the sour taste comes from vinegar added at the end. In traditional recipes, the sourness comes from fermented beet juice or a sourdough starter, which gives a more complex flavor. Modern home cooks often use lemon juice or vinegar as a shortcut, which works fine but is not identical.
How to Choose Between Hot and Cold
Your choice depends on the season and your mood. If it’s winter and you want a hearty, warming meal, go for hot borscht with beef and cabbage. If it’s summer and you want something light and refreshing, cold borscht with kefir and fresh dill is perfect. Both are nutritious, but the cold version is lower in calories and fat, while the hot version is more filling due to the meat and potatoes.
If you’re trying borscht for the first time, start with the hot version—it’s the most famous and gives you the full “borscht experience.” Then, once you’re familiar with the flavor, try the cold version to appreciate the diversity of this soup family.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is borscht served hot or cold? Both. The classic Ukrainian borscht is served hot, but a separate cold version (holodnik or šaltibarščiai) is popular in summer in Lithuania, Poland, and Russia. They are made differently—the cold one uses dairy and no meat.
Can I make cold borscht from leftover hot borscht? Technically you can chill hot borscht, but it won’t be the same as authentic cold borscht. Cold borscht is made with a raw or cooked beet base mixed with kefir or sour cream, not with meat broth. Chilled hot borscht is still tasty, but it’s not the traditional cold dish.
What is the difference between borscht and chłodnik? Chłodnik is the Polish name for cold beet soup, which is essentially a type of cold borscht. It’s often made with young beet leaves and cucumbers, and served with a dollop of sour cream. In Lithuania, the same dish is called šaltibarščiai.
Is borscht healthy? Borscht is generally nutritious—it’s high in fiber, vitamins (especially from beets and cabbage), and antioxidants. The hot version with meat provides protein and iron, while the cold version with kefir offers probiotics. However, the sour cream garnish adds fat and calories, so it’s best enjoyed in moderation.
Can I freeze borscht? Yes, hot borscht freezes well for up to 3 months. Cold borscht, however, does not freeze well because the dairy base can separate and become watery when thawed. For cold borscht, it’s best to make it fresh and eat within 2-3 days.
Final Thoughts
So, is borscht a cold soup? No, not as a rule—but the cold version is a beloved summer tradition in several countries. The word “borscht” encompasses a wide range of soups, from hearty meat-and-beet stews to light, dairy-based chilled blends. The best way to understand is to try both: a steaming bowl of Ukrainian borscht in winter, and a refreshing glass of Lithuanian šaltibarščiai in July. Each is a delicious expression of the same sour-soup heritage.