Mets Minor League Blog

Music theory, instruments and musicians

Mets Minor League Blog

Music theory, instruments and musicians

Nutter Butter Santa Cookies Recipe: Fun Holiday Treats for Kids for Christmas Dessert Tables

Nutter Butter Santa Cookies Recipe: Fun Holiday Treats for Kids for Christmas Dessert Tables

These Nutter Butter Santa cookies turn peanut-shaped sandwich cookies into cheerful little Santas with a white chocolate coating, red icing hats, chocolate-chip eyes, and marshmallow pom-poms. They’re a no-bake Christmas treat, so there’s no dough to mix or oven to heat.

This method keeps the decorating manageable: coat the cookie fronts first, let the coating set, then add the faces and hats. The finished cookies are crisp and sweet, with Nutter Butter’s peanut-butter flavor balanced by creamy white coating and a little candy crunch.

Why This Recipe Works

The cookie is already shaped and sandwiched, which gives each Santa a sturdy base and saves the time and mess of cutting out dough. Leaving the backs uncoated also makes the cookies easier to handle while you decorate.

A thin layer of melted coating gives the front a clean white background and helps the decorations adhere. Letting that layer set before piping the hat keeps the red icing from smearing into the face. The same pause makes it easier to position the chocolate-chip eyes and marshmallow pom-pom without them sliding around.

Using candy melts or melting wafers is especially practical here: they’re designed to melt smoothly and set firm without tempering. Work in small batches and use short microwave bursts, because overheated white coating can turn thick or grainy. If you’re decorating with children, set out small bowls of toppings before you melt anything so the coating is ready to work with as soon as it’s smooth.

Ingredients

  • 1 package (about 16 oz; cookie count varies by package) Nutter Butter cookies
  • 1 cup white melting chocolate or white candy melts
  • 1 tube (about 4 oz) red decorating icing
  • 1 tube (about 4 oz) black decorating icing
  • 1/4 cup mini chocolate chips, about 2 per cookie
  • 24 mini marshmallows, 1 per cookie
  • 2 tablespoons sprinkles, optional

Ingredient Notes

Nutter Butter cookies: Their peanut-butter filling and firm sandwich-cookie structure make them easy to hold and decorate. A package’s exact count can vary, so treat the yield as an estimate and adjust the number of eyes and marshmallows to match the cookies you have. Any similarly sized peanut-shaped sandwich cookie can work, though the flavor and shape will differ.

White melting chocolate or candy melts: Choose coating wafers or candy melts for the most straightforward setting. If using white chocolate, select a product meant for melting and follow its package directions; ordinary white chocolate can be more sensitive to heat and may need tempering for a firm, glossy finish. White almond bark is another workable substitute when melted according to its label.

Red and black decorating icing: Ready-to-use tube icing makes small details easy and avoids mixing colors. If you have only red icing, use extra mini chocolate chips for eyes and skip the black accents. A small piping bag or a sandwich bag with a tiny corner snipped can substitute for a tube, though thicker icing may need a slightly larger opening.

Mini chocolate chips and mini marshmallows: Two chips make simple eyes; turn them point-side down if that helps them sit neatly. A mini marshmallow makes a quick hat pom-pom. If yours are unusually large, cut them in half with clean kitchen scissors so they don’t overwhelm the cookie.

Sprinkles: These are optional and work best as small accents on the hat or around the beard. Add them while the icing or coating is still tacky so they stay in place.

Instructions

  1. Prepare the decorating area. Line a baking sheet or tray with parchment paper or a silicone mat, and arrange the cookies in a single layer nearby. Set out the icing, chocolate chips, marshmallows, and optional sprinkles. Make sure the tray is dry; even a little water can make melted coating seize. No oven is needed for this recipe.
  2. Melt the white coating gently. Put the melting chocolate or candy melts in a dry, microwave-safe bowl. Microwave at 50% power for 20 seconds, stir thoroughly, and repeat in 15- to 20-second bursts until only a few small pieces remain. Stir until smooth; residual warmth should melt those last pieces. It should look fluid and glossy, not scorched or lumpy. If your package gives different melting directions, follow those instead. Gentle heat helps prevent the coating from becoming thick and difficult to spread.
  3. Coat the fronts of the cookies. Hold a cookie by its edges and spoon or spread a thin layer of coating over the front face, leaving the back uncovered. A small offset spatula or the back of a teaspoon works well. Aim for an even layer that covers the cookie without pooling heavily around the sides. Set it on the lined tray and repeat. If the coating starts to thicken, warm it for 5 to 10 seconds at 50% power and stir; it should loosen without getting hot.
  4. Let the white coating set. Leave the tray at cool room temperature for about 20 to 30 minutes, or chill it for 10 to 15 minutes until the fronts feel dry and firm to a light touch. The exact time depends on the room and coating. Don’t add the red hat while the white layer is glossy or soft, because the colors can drag together and the toppings may shift.
  5. Pipe each hat and attach its pom-pom. Pipe a red band across the top portion of each cookie, then fill in a simple triangular or rounded hat shape above it. The Nutter Butter’s curved outline gives you a useful guide; leave a visible white area below for the face and beard. Press one mini marshmallow onto the side or tip of the hat while the red icing is still tacky. If the icing has already crusted, add a small dot of fresh icing under the marshmallow so it sticks.
  6. Add the eyes and facial details. Place two mini chocolate chips below the hat, spacing them evenly as eyes. Use a small dot of black icing for a mouth or a few beard accents if you like; a simple face is easier to read than one crowded with details. Press each chip gently until it holds, taking care not to crack the set coating. These details look best when the chips are level and the white space around them remains visible.
  7. Finish with optional sprinkles and let the cookies firm up. Add sprinkles to the red hats or white beard while the icing is still tacky. Leave the cookies on the tray for 15 to 20 minutes, or until the icing and decorations stay in place when the tray is moved. If your room is warm, use the refrigerator for 10 minutes to help them set, then transfer them carefully to a serving plate or storage container.

Servings: about 24 cookies, depending on package count; prep time: 25 minutes; cook time: 0 minutes; total time: about 55 minutes, including setting.

Tips for Success

  • Keep water away from the coating. Use a completely dry bowl, spoon, and work surface. Water droplets or steam can make melted coating seize into a stiff mass.
  • Stir more than you heat. White coating holds its shape even when warm, so frequent stirring helps you judge how melted it is. Stop microwaving when a few small pieces remain and stir them smooth.
  • Make a thin, even face layer. A thick coating can hide the cookie’s shape and take longer to set. Scrape excess from the edges with the spoon before placing each cookie on the tray.
  • Decorate in stages. Let the base coating firm before adding the hat, then attach the marshmallow and eyes while their icing is still tacky. This is more reliable than trying to decorate everything at once.
  • Use a light hand with icing. A small amount gives you more control and keeps the Santa’s face from being covered. If the icing tube is hard to squeeze, warm it in your hands briefly and knead it gently.
  • Make a quick test cookie. Decorate one first to check the icing flow, the size of the hat, and how the marshmallow sits. Adjust your piping before repeating the design across the tray.
  • Give the finished cookies room. Arrange them in one layer while the icing sets. If you need to stack them for storage, wait until every decoration is completely firm and place parchment between layers.

Troubleshooting

The white coating is thick or grainy. It may have overheated or come into contact with moisture. If it is only slightly thick, stir in a small amount of additional unmelted coating and let the bowl’s warmth soften it. If it has seized from water or is badly scorched, it usually won’t return to a smooth coating; start again with a clean, dry bowl and gentler heat.

The coating slides off or pools around the cookie. The coating may be too warm or applied too thickly. Let it stand briefly to cool until it clings to a spoon, stir, and use a thinner layer. Scrape excess from the cookie edges before setting it on the tray.

The red icing smears into the white face. The base layer was probably not fully set, or the icing was pressed and dragged across it. Let the white coating become firm first, then pipe the hat with a light touch. If a small smear happens, cover it with a neat line of icing or a sprinkle rather than rubbing the coating.

The marshmallow or chocolate chips won’t stay put. Add each decoration while the icing is still tacky and press gently. If the icing has dried, use a tiny fresh dot of icing as edible glue. Avoid pushing hard, which can crack the coating underneath.

The cookies look crowded or uneven. Keep the design simple: one red hat, two eyes, and one pom-pom are enough to make the Santa recognizable. If the cookie size varies, use the top curve as a guide and scale the hat and facial details to fit each one.

Variations

Beard-forward Santas: Leave more of the lower cookie white and add a few short black-icing strokes for a moustache or beard texture. Keep the strokes sparse so the face still reads clearly.

Sprinkle hats: Pipe the red hat, then add a few white or holiday-colored sprinkles before the icing sets. You can also use a small sprinkle in place of a marshmallow, though a marshmallow gives the familiar pom-pom shape.

Different expressions: Use black icing for a tiny smile, or place the chocolate chips slightly higher or lower to change the expression. Since the face area is small, make one change at a time and keep the details modest.

Alternative cookie base: A plain oval sandwich cookie or another sturdy, peanut-shaped cookie can be decorated the same way. Check that it sits flat on the tray and has enough front surface for the coating and face.

Allergy-aware swap: Nutter Butter cookies contain peanuts and wheat, and packaged decorations can have additional allergen information. For someone avoiding an ingredient, choose a suitable cookie and check every package label; changing the cookie will also change the flavor and may affect how well it holds together.

What to Serve With It

These cookies fit naturally on a Christmas dessert table alongside simple treats that offer different textures, such as brownies, shortbread, or a bowl of wrapped chocolates. Their peanut-butter flavor is rich, so a platter of fresh fruit can provide a lighter contrast without competing with the holiday decorations.

For a kid-friendly decorating spread, serve them with milk or hot chocolate once the cookies are fully set. If putting them out with other desserts, keep the Santas in a single layer or stand them upright in a shallow dish so the icing faces remain visible. They also make a fun take-home treat when wrapped individually after the decorations are firm.

Make-Ahead, Storage and Reheating

These are best made at least an hour before serving so the coating and icing have plenty of time to set. You can decorate them a day ahead and keep them in an airtight container in a cool, dry place, away from sunlight and heat. For best texture and appearance, use them within about 3 to 5 days; check the package directions for the cookies and icing, and follow any storage instructions that are more specific.

Refrigeration is not usually necessary for cookies made with shelf-stable packaged ingredients, and a humid refrigerator can dull the coating or soften the cookies. If your decorating icing label calls for refrigeration, or you use a perishable homemade topping, refrigerate the cookies promptly and use them within 3 to 4 days. USDA guidance is to refrigerate perishable foods within 2 hours (within 1 hour when the temperature is above 90°F); the standard 3-to-4-day refrigerator window applies to refrigerated leftovers and perishable foods, not as a special rule for shelf-stable candy-coated cookies.

To freeze, place fully set cookies in a single layer in a freezer-safe airtight container, separating layers with parchment. Freeze for up to 2 months for best quality. Thaw them in the closed container at room temperature so condensation forms on the container rather than directly on the decorations. Do not microwave or otherwise reheat these cookies; warming can melt the coating and icing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to bake the cookies?
No. The Nutter Butter cookies are ready to eat, and the white coating and decorations set without baking. The oven temperature is not applicable; keep the oven off.

Can I use white chocolate chips instead of candy melts?
You can, but chips may not melt as fluidly as coating wafers and may need careful melting or tempering to set neatly. Use a product labeled for melting when possible, and follow its package instructions. Avoid adding water to thin the mixture.

Can I dip the whole cookie?
Yes, but dipping the entire cookie uses more coating and can make the finished treat heavier. Coating just the front face gives you a white decorating surface while leaving the back easy to handle. If you want to dip fully, work in small batches and let excess coating drip back into the bowl before setting the cookie down.

How do I make the white coating smooth?
Use a dry bowl and melt slowly at reduced microwave power, stirring between short bursts. Stop heating before every last piece has melted, then stir until smooth. If the product’s package has specific melting directions, use those because different coatings behave differently.

Can children help decorate these?
Yes. An adult should handle the hot bowl and melted coating. Children can place the mini chocolate chips, marshmallows, and sprinkles once the cookie fronts have set, and older children can pipe icing with supervision.

How far ahead can I make them?
For a party, making them the day before is convenient and gives the decorations time to firm. Store them in a cool, dry place in a sealed container, unless an ingredient label requires refrigeration.

Why is the coating dull after chilling?
Some coatings develop a less glossy surface after refrigeration, and condensation can leave marks when cold cookies meet warm, humid air. Chill only as long as needed to set them, then let them come back to room temperature inside a closed container.

How can I transport the cookies without damaging the faces?
Wait until all decorations are firm, then pack the cookies in a snug, single layer in a shallow container. If stacking is unavoidable, separate layers with parchment and avoid placing anything heavy on top.

Nutter Butter Santa Cookies Recipe: Fun Holiday Treats for Kids for Christmas Dessert Tables
Scroll to top