
These Nutter Butter Santa cookies turn peanut-shaped sandwich cookies into little holiday faces with a smooth white coating, a red icing hat, chocolate-chip eyes, and a mini marshmallow pom-pom. They’re a no-bake project, so kids can help decorate without waiting for an oven to heat up.
This version keeps the decorating simple and gives the coating time to set before the icing goes on. The result is crunchy, sweet, and creamy, with the familiar peanut-butter flavor of the cookies under a thin layer of white chocolate. Make them for a party, a cookie plate, or an easy afternoon activity.
Why This Recipe Works
Nutter Butter cookies already have a useful shape for a Santa face: the broad middle becomes the face, and the curved end gives the hat a natural place to sit. There’s no need to cut or reshape them, which keeps the cookies intact and makes decorating easier for younger helpers.
A thin coating of melted white chocolate or candy melts gives the decorations a pale background and helps the eyes and hat stand out. Spreading the coating over the front, rather than fully dunking each cookie, also makes one cup go further and keeps the ridged cookie surface visible around the edges.
The key is letting that coating set before adding the red icing. Icing placed on a warm or soft coating can slide, smear, or pull up the white layer. Once it is firm to the touch, the hat, eyes, and pom-pom are much easier to position. Decorating one cookie at a time lets you add the marshmallow while the red icing is still tacky enough to hold it.
Ingredients
- 1 package Nutter Butter cookies
- 1 cup white melting chocolate or white candy melts
- 2 tablespoons red decorating icing
- 1 tablespoon black decorating icing
- 1/2 cup mini chocolate chips, for the eyes
- 1/2 cup mini marshmallows, for the hat pom-poms
- 2 tablespoons sprinkles, optional
Ingredient Notes
Nutter Butter cookies: Use the regular sandwich cookies, not a crumb or crushed-cookie product. Packages can contain different numbers of cookies, so the finished yield depends on the package. Choose cookies that are whole and dry; cracked cookies are harder to coat and decorate neatly.
White melting chocolate or candy melts: Either works as the pale coating. White candy melts are formulated to melt smoothly for dipping and decorating. White chocolate has a richer, more chocolate-forward flavor, but it can be more sensitive to overheating. Use whichever you have, and follow the package directions if they differ from the gentle microwave method below. White almond bark can also work if its label describes it as suitable for melting.
Decorating icing: Red icing makes the hat, and black icing can add a small mouth or other facial detail. Use thick decorating icing from a tube or a small piping bag; thin writing gel may run on the smooth coating. If you only have red icing, the black detail is optional because the mini chocolate chips already make clear eyes.
Mini chocolate chips: These make small, recognizable eyes without needing a piping tip. Regular chocolate chips are too large for the same look, but you can use their flat sides sparingly if that is what you have.
Mini marshmallows: One mini marshmallow makes a simple hat pom-pom. If you have only large marshmallows, cut them into small pieces with clean kitchen scissors. Keep the pieces small enough to sit securely on the icing.
Sprinkles: These are an optional finishing touch, not a structural ingredient. Choose small sprinkles that will sit on the icing without weighing it down, or leave them off for a cleaner Santa face.
Instructions
- Prepare the decorating area. Line a tray or plate with parchment paper and arrange the cookies in a single layer. Set out the icing, mini chips, marshmallows, and optional sprinkles before melting the coating. The setup should be dry and within reach; melted coating firms quickly, so having the decorations ready prevents rushed work. No oven is needed for this recipe.
- Melt the white coating gently. Put the white melting chocolate or candy melts in a dry, microwave-safe bowl. Microwave at medium power for 20 seconds, stir well, then continue in 10-second bursts, stirring after each one. Stop when the mixture is mostly smooth and a few small pieces remain; stir until those melt from the residual warmth. The coating should look fluid and glossy, not hot, grainy, or steaming. Gentle heating reduces the chance of scorching or seizing. If the package gives a different melting method, follow its directions.
- Coat the cookies. Hold a cookie by its edge and use a small spatula or the back of a spoon to spread a thin layer of white coating over the front. Leave the ridged edge visible if you like, and avoid piling coating into the center. Set each cookie on the lined tray with the coated side facing up. A thin, even layer gives the icing a smooth base and is less likely to crack or slide than a thick coating.
- Let the coating set. Leave the tray at a cool room temperature for about 20 minutes, or until the coating looks matte and feels firm when lightly touched. If your room is warm, refrigerate the tray for about 10 minutes instead. Do not add the icing while the surface is soft: a firm base helps the red hat keep its shape and keeps the facial details in place.
- Pipe on the hats. Use the red icing to draw a curved band across the upper part of each cookie, then fill in a simple cap shape above it. There is no need to cover the whole top; leave a white area below for Santa’s face and beard. Work on a few cookies at a time so the icing stays tacky for the next step. Look for a clearly defined red cap that does not run down the sides.
- Add the face and pom-pom. Place two mini chocolate chips on the white area for eyes, pressing each gently into the coating. Add a small line or dot of black icing for a mouth if desired. Set one mini marshmallow at the end of each red hat while the icing is still soft enough to grip it. The decorations should stay put when the tray is moved gently; if one slides, reposition it before the icing sets.
- Finish and allow everything to firm up. Add a few sprinkles while the icing is tacky, if using. Leave the cookies undisturbed for about 20 minutes, or until the red icing feels set and the marshmallow is secure. If the room is warm or you need them to set sooner, chill them for about 10 minutes. They are ready when the coating and decorations no longer smear with a light touch.
Servings: one package batch, with the number of cookies depending on package size. Prep time: 20 minutes. Cook time: 0 minutes. Total time: about 1 hour, including setting time.
Tips for Success
- Keep water away from the coating. Make sure the bowl, spoon, and spatula are completely dry. Even a small amount of water can make melted chocolate thick and lumpy.
- Use short heating bursts. Stir between bursts instead of waiting for every piece to melt in the microwave. The bowl’s warmth will finish melting small pieces, and gentle heating helps preserve a smooth texture.
- Spread rather than dunk. A thin front coating is easier to control on a ridged sandwich cookie. It also leaves an edge you can hold while decorating.
- Let the base firm up fully. If a fingertip leaves a dent or the coating looks glossy and soft, give it more time. A properly set surface makes the hat and face easier to arrange.
- Make the details small. Two mini chips and a little icing are enough to suggest a face. Oversized features can crowd the white space and make the cookie harder to handle.
- Decorate in an assembly line. Coat all the cookies first, let them set, then pipe a few hats and add their marshmallows and eyes. This is easier than finishing one cookie completely while the rest are still uncoated.
- Give children manageable jobs. Kids can place the chips, marshmallows, and sprinkles; an adult can handle the warm bowl and spread the coating if needed. Keep the melted coating away from little hands until it has cooled enough to work with safely.
Troubleshooting
The coating is thick or grainy. It may have overheated or come into contact with moisture. Stop heating and stir gently. If it is only slightly thick, a few additional seconds at low power may help; if it has seized into a stiff mass, it may not return to a smooth coating. Start a fresh, dry batch rather than trying to force it onto the cookies.
The white coating slides off the cookie. A thick layer can move before it sets, especially if the cookie is warm or handled on its coated face. Use a thinner layer, set the cookie flat, and leave it undisturbed until firm. Hold cookies by their edges during decorating.
The red hat runs or smears. The white base may still be soft, or the icing may be too thin. Wait until the coating is fully set and use thicker decorating icing. Pipe a smaller outline first, then fill it in with a light touch.
The marshmallow will not stay on. It may have been added after the red icing set. Add the pom-pom immediately after piping the hat, pressing just enough for it to grip. If the icing is already firm, add a small dot of fresh icing beneath the marshmallow.
The cookies break while decorating. Handle them by the edges and avoid pressing hard on the centers. Set cracked cookies aside for snacking, and decorate intact ones; the sandwich layers can split if a cookie is squeezed or twisted.
The decorations look uneven. That is normal for a hand-decorated treat, especially when children are helping. If you want a more consistent look, pipe the same simple hat shape on each cookie and use the same number of eyes and the same size marshmallow.
Variations
For a quicker design, use the white coating as the face, pipe a red triangle or curved cap, and add only the eyes and pom-pom. Skip the mouth and sprinkles if you want fewer decorating steps. For a more detailed Santa, add a short line of white icing along the lower edge of the hat as a brim, if you have white decorating icing on hand.
You can use red candy melts instead of red icing for the hat, but melt them separately and apply them only after the white base has set. A small spoon or piping bag gives better control than dipping the whole cookie. If you change the decorations, keep additions small and light so the finished cookie remains easy to pick up.
For a group activity, put each decoration in its own small bowl and let everyone make a different expression. The cookies do not need to look identical; keeping the coating thin and allowing it to set are the two steps that matter most for a tidy result.
What to Serve With It
Serve the cookies with cold milk, hot cocoa, or a cup of tea or coffee for adults. They also fit well on a holiday dessert platter alongside plain sugar cookies, gingerbread, or fresh fruit. Because the cookies are sweet and fairly rich, a simple drink or less-sweet dessert makes a good contrast.
For a party, arrange them in one layer on a flat tray so the marshmallow pom-poms and icing do not get pressed against one another. If you are transporting them, let the decorations set completely first and use parchment between layers only if the container has enough room to avoid crushing the tops.
Make-Ahead, Storage and Reheating
You can decorate these a day ahead. Once the icing and coating are firm, place the cookies in an airtight container and keep them in a cool, dry place if the package labels for all ingredients allow room-temperature storage. They are best for texture when eaten within about a week; warmth and humidity can soften the cookie or make the decorations tacky sooner.
If an ingredient label calls for refrigeration, follow it. For refrigerated storage, keep the cookies in a covered container and use them within 3 to 4 days. Chilling can make the cookies firmer, and condensation may form when a cold container is opened in a warm room. Let the closed container come toward room temperature before opening it to help limit moisture on the decorations.
For longer storage, freeze the fully set cookies in a freezer-safe airtight container for up to 2 months for best quality. Separate layers with parchment and protect the marshmallows from being squashed. Thaw the closed container in the refrigerator or at room temperature, then open it once the cookies are no longer cold. Do not microwave decorated cookies: the coating can melt unevenly and the marshmallows can become sticky. There is no reheating step for this no-bake treat.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to bake the Nutter Butter cookies?
No. The cookies are ready to eat from the package, and the coating and decorations are added without baking. Use a lined tray to let them set.
Can I use white chocolate chips instead of melting wafers?
Yes, but chips may melt thicker than candy melts and can be less convenient to spread. Heat them gently and stir often. If the mixture remains too thick to coat the cookie in a thin layer, use melting wafers or candy melts instead of adding water.
Can I melt the coating on the stovetop?
Yes. Set a heatproof bowl over a saucepan containing gently simmering water, making sure the bowl does not touch the water and no steam or water gets into the coating. Stir until smooth, then remove the bowl carefully. A microwave is simply a convenient option for a small batch.
How do I make the cookies look like Santa?
Keep the lower portion white for the face and beard, pipe a red cap across the upper portion, and add two mini-chip eyes and a marshmallow at the hat tip. A small black icing detail can suggest a mouth, but it is optional.
Can I make these without black icing?
Yes. The mini chocolate chips make the eyes, and the face still reads clearly without a mouth. You can also leave off the optional sprinkles for a simple finish.
What can I use if I do not have a piping bag?
Use icing from a decorating tube, or put thick icing in a small food-storage bag and snip a tiny corner. Start with a very small opening; you can enlarge it if needed, but a large opening makes a neat hat harder to pipe.
Why did my white coating turn dull?
A matte finish is normal as the coating sets. If it looks streaky or grainy rather than evenly matte, it may have been overheated, stirred with a damp utensil, or handled before fully set. Keep the bowl and tools dry and use gentle heat.
Can I freeze the finished cookies?
Yes. Freeze them only after the decorations have set, pack them carefully so the marshmallows are not crushed, and thaw them in a closed container. The cookie and coating should hold, though the icing or marshmallow texture may be a little less tidy after thawing.