
Peanut butter and jelly bread pudding turns familiar sandwich flavors into a warm, spoonable bake: cubes of soft bread soak up a vanilla egg custard, with creamy peanut butter and sweet-tart jelly running through the layers. It’s an easy dessert or brunch dish, and a good way to use bread that’s a little stale.
This version keeps the peanut butter and jelly distinct instead of blending them into the custard. Gently warming each makes it easy to drizzle between the bread, while a short soak gives the cubes time to absorb the milk and eggs. The finished pudding is soft and custardy inside, lightly golden at the edges, and rich with peanut butter and jam in every serving.
Why This Recipe Works
Day-old brioche or challah has enough structure to absorb custard without immediately collapsing. Fresh bread can work, but it is softer and may turn mushy; drying it briefly in the oven gives it a more absorbent surface. Cutting the bread into fairly even cubes also helps the pudding bake at a consistent rate.
The custard is mixed separately before it meets the bread. That makes it easier to distribute the eggs, milk, sugar, and vanilla evenly, rather than leaving pockets of egg white or dry sugar. A short rest before baking lets the bread absorb some of the liquid, so the center is less likely to be dry while the edges overcook.
Peanut butter and jelly are thick when cold, so trying to spread them across loose bread cubes can crush the bread and leave uneven clumps. Warming them just until pourable makes layering much easier. They remain in ribbons as the pudding bakes, giving the finished dish a mix of creamy, fruity, and custardy bites.
Ingredients
- 4 cups day-old bread, cut into roughly 1-inch cubes; brioche or challah works especially well
- 1 cup creamy or crunchy peanut butter
- 1 cup jelly or jam, such as grape or strawberry
- 4 large eggs
- 2 cups whole milk
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon, optional
- 1 tablespoon butter, or enough non-stick cooking spray to coat a 2-quart baking dish
Ingredient Notes
Bread: Brioche and challah are tender, rich breads that soak up custard well and make a soft, dessert-like pudding. Plain sandwich bread, French bread, or another sturdy loaf can also work. If your bread is very fresh, spread the cubes on a baking sheet and dry them in a 300°F oven for about 10 to 15 minutes, just until they feel less moist but are not browned.
Peanut butter: Creamy peanut butter makes smooth ribbons; crunchy peanut butter adds small pieces of peanut throughout. Either conventional or natural peanut butter can be used, but stir natural peanut butter thoroughly first so the oil is incorporated. If it is unusually thick, warm it gently with a few seconds of microwave heat at a time until it can be drizzled.
Jelly or jam: Grape and strawberry are classic choices, but raspberry, blackberry, or another smooth fruit spread also works. Jam with fruit pieces is fine; warming it briefly makes it easier to distribute. If your spread is very firm, stir in a teaspoon of water to loosen it, adding more only if needed.
Eggs and milk: Eggs set the custard as it bakes, while whole milk gives it a tender texture. Two percent milk can be substituted, though the result may be a little less rich. Avoid replacing the milk with a very watery plant beverage unless you are comfortable with a softer, less creamy result.
Sugar, vanilla, and cinnamon: The sugar sweetens the custard and helps the top brown. Vanilla rounds out the peanut butter and fruit flavors. Cinnamon is optional; leave it out for a flavor closer to a classic PB&J sandwich, or include it for a warmer, bakery-style note.
Instructions
- Heat the oven and prepare the dish. Set a rack in the center of the oven and heat it to 350°F. Butter a 2-quart baking dish or coat it evenly with non-stick spray. A dish around 8 inches square works well if it holds 2 quarts. Greasing the corners and sides helps prevent sticking and makes serving easier.
- Check the bread and warm the spreads. Put the bread cubes in a large bowl. If the bread is fresh or very soft, dry the cubes on a baking sheet at 300°F for 10 to 15 minutes, then let them cool briefly. Warm the peanut butter and jelly separately in microwave-safe bowls in short bursts, stirring between each, until each is loose enough to drizzle but not hot. This makes even ribbons without crushing the bread.
- Mix the custard. In a medium bowl, whisk the eggs until the yolks and whites are fully combined. Whisk in the milk, sugar, vanilla, and cinnamon if using. The mixture should look even, with no streaks of egg white or dry sugar. Mixing thoroughly now helps every part of the bread pudding bake with the same custard texture.
- Layer the bread, peanut butter, and jelly. Arrange about half of the bread cubes in the prepared dish. Drizzle roughly half of the peanut butter and half of the jelly over the cubes, moving across the dish rather than pouring everything in one spot. Add the remaining bread, then drizzle on the remaining spreads. The layers do not need to be perfect; a few thicker ribbons are fine.
- Add the custard and let the bread soak. Pour the egg mixture slowly and evenly over the bread. Press the cubes down gently with the back of a spoon so they make contact with the custard, without packing them tightly. Let the dish stand for 10 to 15 minutes. The bread should look damp throughout, and a little custard may remain visible between the cubes; this rest helps the middle bake through.
- Bake until the center is set. Bake at 350°F for 45 to 55 minutes. Begin checking near the 45-minute mark. The top should be lightly golden, the edges should look set, and the center should have only a slight jiggle rather than a loose, liquid wobble. For a direct check, insert an instant-read thermometer into the center of the custard, avoiding a thick ribbon of peanut butter; it should reach 160°F. If the top is browning before the center sets, loosely cover the dish with foil and continue baking.
- Rest, then serve. Set the dish on a heat-safe surface and let it rest for 10 to 15 minutes before serving. The custard will firm up a little as it stands, making portions easier to lift. Serve warm with a spoon, taking care because the fruit and peanut butter pockets can hold heat.
Tips for Success
- Use stale bread, not stale-tasting bread. Day-old bread should be dry at the surface but still smell fresh. If it has an off smell, visible mold, or an unpleasant texture, discard it rather than trying to bake with it.
- Keep the cubes close to 1 inch. Smaller pieces can become dense and soft, while very large pieces may stay dry in the middle. Similar-sized cubes help the custard soak in at a similar rate.
- Warm the spreads only enough to loosen them. Hot peanut butter or jam can make the bread soggy in isolated spots and is harder to handle. Short microwave bursts with a stir between them are easier to control than one long heating time.
- Pour the custard slowly. Move around the dish so the top layer is not flooded in one area. Give the bread a chance to absorb the liquid before baking, especially if the cubes are very dry.
- Use the center as your doneness guide. Browning at the edges is useful, but it does not prove the egg custard in the middle is set. Look for the set-but-slightly-jiggly cue and check that the center reaches 160°F.
- Let it rest before portioning. A short rest lets the hot custard settle and makes the pudding less likely to fall apart when served. It will still be pleasantly warm after 10 to 15 minutes.
Troubleshooting
The center is still loose after the stated bake time. Ovens, dish shapes, and bread moisture vary. Continue baking in 5-minute increments, loosely covering the top with foil if it is already brown. Check the center again; it should reach 160°F and should not look liquid.
The top is dry or the edges are tough. The pudding may have baked too long, or the bread may have been very dry and not evenly moistened. Next time, press the cubes gently into the custard and give them the full 10- to 15-minute soak. Start checking doneness at 45 minutes rather than waiting for the top to become deeply browned.
There are dry bread cubes on top. Some exposed corners are normal, but large dry patches can mean the custard was poured unevenly. Before baking, press the cubes gently into the liquid and spoon any visible custard over dry areas. Avoid compressing the whole mixture, which can make it heavy.
The peanut butter or jelly formed large clumps. The spreads may have been too cold or too thick to drizzle. Warm them briefly and stir until fluid before layering. If the pudding is already assembled, the clumps will still bake safely, but the flavor will be less evenly distributed.
The pudding seems very sweet. The recipe includes sugar in the custard as well as sweet jelly or jam. For a less sweet result next time, use a tart fruit spread or reduce the granulated sugar to 3/4 cup. That change will not affect the basic method, though the custard will taste less sweet.
Variations
Change the fruit spread to suit what you have: raspberry or blackberry gives a tart contrast, while apricot makes a milder, softer fruit note. You can also use one flavor on one half of the dish and another flavor on the other half, which is handy when serving a group with different preferences.
For a more pronounced cinnamon flavor, use the optional 1/2 teaspoon in the custard. A small pinch of ground nutmeg can be added as well, but keep it modest so it does not overwhelm the peanut butter and fruit. If you like more texture, use crunchy peanut butter or scatter a small handful of chopped roasted peanuts over the top after baking.
For individual portions, divide the layered mixture among greased oven-safe ramekins, leaving room for the custard to rise slightly. Place the ramekins on a baking sheet and begin checking earlier than you would for the large dish; the exact time depends on their size and depth. Use the same visual cues and 160°F center temperature rather than relying only on the clock.
What to Serve With It
This pudding is rich enough to serve on its own as dessert. A spoonful of plain or lightly sweetened yogurt, a little whipped cream, or fresh fruit provides a cool contrast. If serving it for brunch, pair it with something savory, such as eggs or crisp bacon, and fresh fruit to balance the sweet, custardy portion.
It is best warm, but it does not need an elaborate topping. A thin drizzle of warmed jam or a small extra spoonful of peanut butter works if you want to echo the flavors already in the dish. Keep toppings modest; the pudding itself contains plenty of sweetness and richness.
Make-Ahead, Storage and Reheating
Make ahead: Assemble the bread and custard in the greased dish, cover it, and refrigerate it for up to overnight before baking. For best texture, warm the peanut butter and jelly enough to drizzle before assembling. The bread will absorb more custard during the longer chill, so bake it directly from the refrigerator and allow extra time if needed. Check the center for doneness rather than assuming the original bake time will be exact. Do not leave an egg-and-milk mixture at room temperature while preparing ahead.
Refrigerate leftovers: Refrigerate within 2 hours of baking, storing portions in a covered container or covering the baking dish. Keep refrigerated leftovers for 3 to 4 days. If the room or outdoor temperature is above 90°F, refrigerate within 1 hour. These time limits help keep perishable egg-and-milk dishes safely chilled.
Freeze: For longer storage, freeze cooled portions in airtight, freezer-safe packaging. They are best used within 2 to 3 months for quality. Thaw in the refrigerator, not on the counter. Freezing may soften the bread texture, but the pudding can still be reheated and served.
Reheat: Warm an individual portion in the microwave in short intervals until hot throughout, or cover a larger portion and heat it in a 325°F oven until warmed through. Reheat leftovers to 165°F. If reheating a whole dish, keep it covered so the surface does not dry out; uncover briefly at the end if you want to refresh the top.
Recipe Card
Servings: 6 to 8
Prep time: 20 minutes
Cook time: 45 to 55 minutes
Total time: About 1 hour 15 minutes, including the resting time
Ingredients
- 4 cups day-old brioche or challah, cut into roughly 1-inch cubes
- 1 cup creamy or crunchy peanut butter
- 1 cup jelly or jam, such as grape or strawberry
- 4 large eggs
- 2 cups whole milk
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon, optional
- 1 tablespoon butter or enough non-stick cooking spray to grease a 2-quart baking dish
Condensed Instructions
- Heat the oven to 350°F. Grease a 2-quart baking dish. If the bread is fresh, dry the cubes at 300°F for 10 to 15 minutes.
- Warm the peanut butter and jelly separately until loose enough to drizzle. Whisk the eggs, milk, sugar, vanilla, and optional cinnamon until smooth.
- Layer half the bread in the dish, drizzle with half the peanut butter and jelly, then repeat with the remaining bread and spreads.
- Pour the custard evenly over the bread. Press the cubes gently into it and let stand for 10 to 15 minutes.
- Bake for 45 to 55 minutes, until the center is set with a slight jiggle and reaches 160°F. Cover loosely with foil if the top browns too quickly.
- Rest for 10 to 15 minutes before serving warm.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use fresh bread?
Yes. Fresh bread can be softer and may absorb custard unevenly, so dry the cubes in a 300°F oven for 10 to 15 minutes first. Let them cool briefly before layering. You want bread that is less moist at the surface, not toasted or browned.
Do I need to remove the crusts?
No. The crusts soften as they absorb the custard and add a little structure. If your loaf has especially tough crusts and you prefer a more uniform texture, you can trim them, but it is not necessary.
Can I assemble the pudding the night before?
Yes. Cover the assembled dish and refrigerate it overnight, then bake it the next day. Because cold pudding takes longer to heat through, allow extra baking time and check the center for a set texture and a temperature of 160°F.
Can I use a different kind of milk?
Two percent milk can be used in place of whole milk, with a slightly less rich result. A very thin milk alternative may make the custard less creamy, and products vary in sweetness and composition. Whatever you use, keep the quantity at 2 cups and check doneness by the center rather than the clock alone.
Can I use natural peanut butter?
Yes. Stir it very well so the separated oil is incorporated before measuring. Natural peanut butter can be thicker or looser than conventional peanut butter, so warm it gently until it drizzles. Avoid overheating it.
How do I know when bread pudding is done?
The edges should look set, the center should have only a slight jiggle, and there should be no liquid custard visible. For an egg-based dish, an instant-read thermometer in the center should register 160°F. A large peanut butter ribbon can affect a reading, so check a nearby custard area.
Can I serve it cold?
Yes, though the texture is firmer when chilled and the peanut butter is less soft. For the most tender, custardy texture, serve it warm after its short resting period. Refrigerate any portion you are not serving promptly.
Can I make it less sweet?
Use a tart jam or reduce the custard sugar from 1 cup to 3/4 cup. The original amount gives a clearly dessert-like result, especially with sweet grape or strawberry jelly. If you make the change, the baking method remains the same; still check that the center is set and reaches 160°F.
![Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Bread Pudding [recipe in description]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/2pTBBro04hY/hqdefault.jpg)