Mets Minor League Blog

Music theory, instruments and musicians

Mets Minor League Blog

Music theory, instruments and musicians

Quick Ninja Eggnog Slushie Recipes

Quick Ninja Eggnog Slushie Recipes

This quick Ninja eggnog slushie blends chilled eggnog with ice and a little nutmeg into a creamy, frosty drink in about five minutes. The simple base recipe is easy to adjust for sweetness and thickness, and the variations below make it simple to serve alcohol-free or add a different seasonal flavor.

Ingredients

  • 1 1/2 cups cold eggnog
  • 2 cups ice cubes
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg, plus a little extra for serving
  • 1/4 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon granulated sugar, optional, only if you want a sweeter drink

This makes about 2 servings. Use eggnog straight from the refrigerator, rather than letting it warm on the counter. The sugar is optional because many prepared eggnogs are already sweet; taste the finished drink before adding more.

Instructions

  1. Chill the ingredients and glasses. Keep the eggnog refrigerated until you are ready to blend. If you have time, place two serving glasses in the freezer for 10 to 15 minutes. Cold glasses help the slushie stay frosty while you serve it, but this step is optional.
  2. Load the blender. Pour the eggnog into the Ninja blender pitcher first, then add the ice, nutmeg, vanilla, and optional sugar. Adding the liquid before the ice gives the blades something to draw down around them. Secure the lid and make sure the pitcher is seated correctly on the base.
  3. Break up the ice. Use the pulse function in short bursts, or the ice-crushing setting if your particular blender has one. Pause once or twice to check the mixture. If large pieces remain, pulse again rather than running the blender for a long time right away.
  4. Blend until slushy. Blend on a high setting for about 20 to 40 seconds, stopping sooner if the mixture is already smooth and thick. Blender power and ice size vary, so use the texture as your guide rather than relying only on the clock. The finished drink should look evenly frosted, with no large ice chunks, but should still be thick enough to sip through a wide straw.
  5. Adjust the consistency. If the mixture is too thick to move around the pitcher, stop the blender and add cold eggnog 1 tablespoon at a time, blending briefly after each addition. If it is too loose, add a few ice cubes and pulse. Taste a spoonful; blend in the optional sugar only if it needs extra sweetness.
  6. Serve right away. Pour into the chilled glasses, finish with a small pinch of nutmeg, and serve immediately. If you are making more than one batch, keep the first batch in the freezer while you blend the next, but do not leave it there long enough to freeze solid.

Tips

  • Start with cold eggnog. Warm liquid melts the ice faster and can make the drink thin before it reaches the table. If your eggnog has been sitting out, return it to the refrigerator until properly chilled rather than trying to compensate with a large amount of extra ice.
  • Use the pulse button before a long blend. Ice cubes can settle or bridge above the blades. Short pulses help break them up; a long uninterrupted blend can warm the mixture and turn a thick slush into a thinner drink. Stop the motor before scraping down the sides, and use only the tamper supplied for your blender, if applicable.
  • Make small consistency changes. Add eggnog a tablespoon at a time to loosen the mixture, or a few ice cubes at a time to thicken it. Large additions can swing the texture too far in either direction. Different brands of eggnog also vary in thickness and sweetness, so a small adjustment is normal.
  • Check your appliance instructions. Ninja blender models differ in their controls and capacities. Do not exceed the fill line, and use the settings recommended in your manual for crushing ice. If your pitcher is smaller, blend the recipe in batches rather than packing in the ingredients.

Serving Suggestions

Serve the slushie as a dessert drink after dinner, or offer small glasses alongside holiday cookies, gingerbread, shortbread, or a slice of plain pound cake. Its rich, spiced flavor is satisfying, so modest portions work well, especially after a full meal. A pinch of freshly grated nutmeg gives a fragrant finish; cinnamon is another easy garnish. For a simple presentation, pour the drink into chilled glasses just before serving and add a cinnamon stick if you have one. Avoid adding whipped cream until the last moment, since it can soften and sink into the icy surface.

For a gathering, set out the chilled eggnog and spices, then blend the ice in batches as guests are ready to drink. Keep the unblended eggnog in the refrigerator between batches and return the pitcher to the freezer briefly if it has become warm, following the appliance manual. Do not leave a dairy-based drink sitting out for a long stretch; serve it promptly and discard any portion that has been at room temperature for more than two hours, or one hour in temperatures above 90°F.

Variations

More spice: Add 1/8 teaspoon ground cinnamon with the nutmeg, then taste before adding more. A small pinch of ground cloves can also work, but its flavor is strong, so use just a pinch. Keep the total seasoning modest; cold drinks can taste less aromatic than warm ones, but too much spice can make the texture gritty.

Maple version: Replace the optional granulated sugar with 1 teaspoon maple syrup. Blend it with the eggnog and spices, then taste. Maple syrup adds its own flavor, so it is a good match if you want a less plain, more dessert-like drink. Do not pour in a large amount at once, since extra liquid can thin the slush.

Chocolate eggnog slushie: Add 1 tablespoon unsweetened cocoa powder to the blender. For fewer cocoa clumps, whisk the cocoa into a couple of tablespoons of the eggnog first, then add that mixture to the pitcher with the remaining ingredients. Taste before sweetening; cocoa is bitter, but the eggnog may already provide enough sweetness.

Alcohol-free or lightly spiked: The base recipe is alcohol-free as written. For an adult version, blend in up to 1 tablespoon of bourbon or dark rum per serving after the slush has formed, using short pulses to combine. Alcohol lowers the freezing point and can make the drink softer, so avoid adding a large pour if you want a thick, spoonable texture. Clearly label spiked servings and keep them separate from alcohol-free ones.

Dairy-free option: Use a dairy-free eggnog alternative in the same amount, checking its label for sweetness and thickness. Some alternatives are thinner than dairy eggnog, so begin with 1 1/2 cups and add more only if the blender needs help moving the ice. The final texture will depend on the product you choose.

Storage and Reheating

This slushie is best immediately after blending. Ice starts melting as soon as it is combined with eggnog, so refrigeration will not preserve the slushy texture. If you need to wait a few minutes, place the covered pitcher in the freezer briefly and check it often; if the edges begin to freeze hard, stir or pulse the mixture before pouring. Do not store it at room temperature while you prepare other parts of a meal.

For the best texture, do not make the finished drink hours ahead. If you have leftovers, transfer them to a covered, freezer-safe container and freeze promptly. The mixture will become solid rather than staying slushy, and its texture may be less smooth after thawing. For best quality, use it within about one day: let it soften in the refrigerator just until a spoon can break it up, then blend briefly with a splash of cold eggnog. Do not reheat it; heat melts the ice and makes a warm eggnog drink rather than a slushie.

Keep any unused eggnog refrigerated according to its package directions, and return it to the refrigerator promptly after pouring. Follow the date and storage instructions on the carton; do not use eggnog that smells or looks spoiled. Wash the blender pitcher, lid, and utensils after use, especially before making another batch for guests with different dietary needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this without a Ninja blender?

Yes. A countertop blender that is designed to crush ice can make the same recipe. Use its pulse or ice-crushing function, if available, and follow the manufacturer’s directions. If your blender is not intended for ice, do not force it to process hard cubes; use smaller or crushed ice only if the appliance manual permits that.

Why is my eggnog slushie runny?

The eggnog may not have been cold enough, the blender may have run long enough to melt the ice, or the ice-to-liquid balance may be too low for your ingredients. Add a few ice cubes and pulse briefly. Next time, start with refrigerated eggnog and stop blending as soon as the mixture is evenly slushy.

Why is the blender struggling to mix everything?

The mixture may be too thick, the ice may be packed above the blades, or the pitcher may be overfilled. Stop the blender before adjusting anything. Add cold eggnog a tablespoon at a time, then pulse again. If the pitcher is above its fill line, remove some ingredients and blend in batches.

Can I use crushed ice instead of cubes?

Yes, crushed ice works, but it melts faster and can make the finished drink thinner. Begin with about 1 1/2 cups crushed ice instead of 2 cups of cubes, pulse, and add more a little at a time if needed. The exact amount depends on how finely the ice is crushed and how thick the eggnog is.

Can I make a larger batch?

You can scale the ingredients up, provided the total amount stays within your blender’s capacity and below its maximum fill line. For a crowded pitcher or a less powerful model, two smaller batches are easier to blend evenly. Serve each batch promptly; keeping the liquid and ice separate until blending time usually gives a better texture than storing a large prepared slush.

Can I prepare the ingredients in advance?

Yes. Measure the spices and keep them covered, and keep the eggnog refrigerated until you are ready to blend. You can chill the glasses ahead of time as well. For the best consistency, wait to combine the eggnog and ice until just before serving, since the ice begins to melt as soon as it is blended.

Quick Ninja Eggnog Slushie Recipes
Scroll to top