Mets Minor League Blog

Music theory, instruments and musicians

Mets Minor League Blog

Music theory, instruments and musicians

Soft and Chewy Sourdough Bagels: A Step-by-Step Guide

Soft and Chewy Sourdough Bagels: A Step-by-Step Guide

These sourdough bagels have a thin, glossy crust and a pleasantly chewy middle, with a mild tang from an active starter. The dough is mixed and shaped by hand, boiled briefly, then baked until deeply golden.

This version keeps the ingredient list simple and the dough firm enough to shape without a stand mixer. A lively starter, a patient rise, and the short baking-soda bath are the keys to bagels that hold their shape and taste balanced rather than sharply sour.

Why This Recipe Works

The starter supplies both flavor and leavening. Because it is fed and active, it can raise the dough without commercial yeast; the trade-off is that the rise follows the starter’s strength and the room’s temperature, not a fixed clock. Look for a noticeably puffy dough rather than relying on time alone.

This is a relatively firm dough. That makes it easier to divide, roll, and shape into rings, and it helps the bagels keep a defined hole as they proof and boil. The starter also contributes flour and water, so the dough is not as dry as the initial ingredient list might suggest.

Boiling sets the outside of each bagel before it goes into the oven. Baking soda makes the bath alkaline, encouraging a well-browned crust and a distinctive bagel surface. A short boil keeps the crust pleasantly chewy instead of thick and tough. Baking at a hot temperature finishes the center while giving the outside color.

Ingredients

  • 500 grams all-purpose flour, plus a little extra for the work surface if needed
  • 300 grams active sourdough starter at equal weights flour and water, bubbly and recently fed
  • 200 grams lukewarm water, about 95°F
  • 10 grams fine salt, about 1 ½ teaspoons
  • 1 tablespoon malt syrup or honey, optional
  • 2 quarts water, for the boiling bath
  • 1 tablespoon baking soda, for the boiling bath
  • 2 tablespoons sesame seeds, optional topping
  • 2 tablespoons poppy seeds, optional topping
  • 2 tablespoons everything bagel seasoning, optional topping
  • 1 tablespoon coarse sea salt, optional topping

Ingredient Notes

Flour: All-purpose flour makes a sturdy bagel with a tender, chewy bite. Bread flour can replace it gram for gram for a firmer, chewier result. Avoid adding much extra flour while kneading; the dough should be firm but still come together cleanly.

Starter: Use a starter that is active and bubbly, not one taken straight from a long, unfed spell in the refrigerator. The starter in this formula contains equal weights flour and water. If yours is sluggish, feed it and wait until it has risen and looks aerated before mixing. A weak starter can make the dough take much longer to rise.

Water: Lukewarm water helps the starter begin fermenting comfortably. It should feel warm, not hot. Cooler water is fine, but the rise will take longer. Since flour absorbs water differently, hold back a small splash at first if your flour is already very dry, then add it only if the dough will not come together.

Salt: Salt seasons the dough and keeps the flavor from tasting flat. Fine salt disperses easily. If using a coarser salt, weigh it rather than measuring by volume because crystals vary in size.

Malt syrup or honey: This is optional. Malt syrup gives a gentle malty note; honey adds a little sweetness. Either can be left out without changing the shaping method. Do not confuse the optional dough sweetener with the baking soda bath.

Toppings: Use one topping or a mix. Coarse salt is easiest to apply sparingly. Seeds and seasoning adhere best when added just after the bagels leave the bath, while their surfaces are still damp.

Instructions

  1. Check the starter. Make sure it is bubbly, has risen after feeding, and smells pleasantly tangy rather than sharply unpleasant. If it is not active, feed it and wait until it shows clear signs of fermentation. A lively starter is essential because it is the dough’s only leavener.
  2. Mix the dough. In a large bowl, stir together the starter, 200 grams lukewarm water, and the malt syrup or honey if using. Add the flour and salt. Mix until no dry flour remains; the dough will feel stiff and rough. Cover and rest for 15 minutes so the flour can hydrate, which makes kneading easier.
  3. Knead until smooth. Knead on a clean work surface for about 8 to 10 minutes, pressing and folding the dough until it becomes cohesive, smooth, and elastic. It should feel firm and slightly tacky but should not smear across your hands. If it is crumbly after thorough kneading, work in water a teaspoon at a time. If very sticky, knead a little longer before dusting with flour; too much extra flour can make the bagels dense.
  4. Begin the bulk rise. Put the dough in a lightly oiled bowl, turn it once to coat, and cover. Leave it at a comfortable room temperature for about 4 to 6 hours, checking sooner if the room is warm. The dough should look puffier and feel lighter, with some air inside, but it may not double. Sourdough timing varies, so use these cues as well as the clock.
  5. Divide and pre-shape. Turn the dough onto the work surface and divide it into 8 equal pieces. Shape each into a tight ball by drawing the edges underneath and rolling it gently against the counter. Cover the balls and let them relax for 10 minutes; this brief rest reduces spring-back when you form the rings.
  6. Shape the bagels. Poke a hole through the center of each ball with a floured finger, then gently stretch the opening until it is about 2 inches across. Alternatively, roll each piece into a rope and pinch the ends together firmly. Make the hole wider than you think it needs to be, because it will shrink as the dough rises and bakes. Set the shaped bagels on parchment, leaving space between them.
  7. Proof until puffy. Cover loosely and let the bagels sit for about 1 to 2 hours, depending on room temperature and starter strength. They should look slightly expanded and feel airy, while still springing back slowly when gently pressed. To check one, place it in a bowl of cool water: if it floats within about 10 seconds, it is ready to boil. If it sinks, dry it gently, return it to the tray, and proof longer before testing again.
  8. Heat the oven and prepare the bath. Toward the end of proofing, heat the oven to 425°F and line a baking sheet with parchment. Bring 2 quarts water to a gentle boil in a wide pot, then stir in 1 tablespoon baking soda. Keep the bath at a steady simmer rather than a violent boil, which can rough up the bagels.
  9. Boil the bagels. Lower the bagels into the bath in batches without crowding the pot. Boil for 30 seconds on the first side and 30 seconds on the other, turning with a slotted spoon. They should puff slightly and look set on the surface. Lift them out, let excess water drain, and place them on the prepared sheet. Add toppings while the surfaces are damp so they stick.
  10. Bake until browned. Bake at 425°F for 20 to 25 minutes, rotating the sheet once if your oven browns unevenly. The bagels are ready when they are a rich golden brown, feel firm on the outside, and sound hollow when tapped on the bottom. Transfer to a rack and cool for at least 20 minutes before slicing; the crumb continues to set as it cools.

Tips for Success

  • Use a ripe starter. A starter that has risen and looks aerated gives a more predictable dough than one that is dormant. If your kitchen is cool, expect the fermentation to take longer.
  • Keep the dough firm. Bagel dough should be noticeably stiffer than many sandwich-bread doughs. Resist the urge to add water unless it remains crumbly after kneading.
  • Shape with a generous opening. The center hole closes somewhat during proofing and baking. A wider opening at shaping helps the finished bagel keep its familiar ring.
  • Do not crowd the bath. Give each bagel room to move. Crowding lowers the water temperature and makes turning awkward.
  • Watch the dough, not just the clock. A warm room and vigorous starter speed fermentation; a cool room or less active starter slows it. Puffy, airy dough is the useful cue.
  • Cool before cutting. Slicing while hot can compress the crumb and make the center seem gummy. Let the bagels cool on a rack first.

Troubleshooting

The dough has barely risen. The starter may not have been active enough, or the room may be cool. Give the covered dough more time in a comfortably warm place. For the next batch, use the starter after it has risen well from a feeding.

The dough is dry and will not hold together. Flour may have absorbed more water than expected, or the starter may be stiffer than assumed. Knead in water a teaspoon at a time until the dough becomes cohesive. Add slowly; a little changes a firm dough quickly.

The shaped rings keep shrinking. The dough is resisting because it has not relaxed. Cover the pieces and wait 10 minutes, then stretch the holes gently again. Avoid pulling hard enough to tear the surface.

The bagels are dense. Common causes are an underactive starter, insufficient proofing, or too much extra flour during kneading and shaping. Look for visible puffiness before boiling and keep the work surface only lightly floured.

The holes close up. Stretch them wider during shaping and avoid overproofing, which can weaken the ring. A hole about 2 inches wide before proofing is a useful starting point.

The crust is pale or soft. Confirm that the oven is fully heated, and bake until the bagels are deeply golden rather than taking them out as soon as they feel firm. Check that the baking soda has been stirred into the bath.

The crust is tough. The bagels may have boiled too long or baked beyond the point of deep browning. Keep the bath to about 30 seconds per side and begin checking near the shorter end of the bake time.

Variations

Seeded bagels: Top with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, or everything bagel seasoning after boiling. For a mixed topping, combine a little of each and press it gently onto the damp surface.

Salt bagels: Sprinkle coarse sea salt lightly over the bagels after the bath. Salt draws moisture from the surface over time, so these are best eaten soon after baking.

Honey-sweetened dough: Use honey in the dough for a faint sweetness that pairs well with sesame or plain cream cheese. Leave it out if you prefer a more savory bagel.

Chewier bagels: Swap the all-purpose flour for bread flour. The dough may feel a little firmer, but the method and water amount can stay the same; add water only if the dough cannot come together.

Plain bagels: Skip all toppings. The baking-soda bath still gives the outside color and chew, so the bagels do not need a topping to be complete.

What to Serve With It

Split and toast a cooled bagel, then add cream cheese, butter, or a savory spread. For a simple breakfast, pair it with scrambled eggs or fruit. Smoked salmon, sliced cucumber, and a little cream cheese make a familiar savory filling; keep any perishable fillings refrigerated until serving.

Plain bagels also work well with jam, nut butter, or a sharp cheese. If serving a group, offer toppings separately so people can choose sweet or savory combinations without making the crust soggy in advance.

Make-Ahead, Storage and Reheating

Make ahead: For a slower schedule, shape the bagels, cover the tray well, and refrigerate overnight. The next day, let them sit at room temperature while you heat the oven and prepare the bath. If they still look tight and have not become puffy, give them more time before boiling. Cold dough may need a longer proof.

Room-temperature storage: Once completely cool, keep the bagels in a sealed bag or airtight container for a couple of days. They are usually best on the day they are baked. Avoid sealing them while warm, which traps moisture and softens the crust.

Refrigerator: Refrigeration can make bread stale faster, so it is not the best choice for keeping bagels at their best. If you do refrigerate them, wrap them well and use within three to four days, consistent with general USDA guidance for refrigerated leftovers.

Freezer: For longer storage, freeze fully cooled bagels in a well-sealed freezer bag for up to three months. Freeze them whole or sliced, separating slices with parchment if you want to toast only part of a bagel. Thaw at room temperature or toast slices straight from frozen.

Reheating: Toast halves until warm and crisp. To refresh a whole bagel, sprinkle the outside lightly with water and heat in a 350°F oven for about 5 to 8 minutes. The crust softens as it warms and firms again as it cools briefly.

Recipe Card

Servings: 8 bagels
Prep time: About 45 minutes active, plus rising
Cook time: About 25 minutes, in batches for boiling and baking
Total time: About 8 to 10 hours, mostly unattended rise time

Ingredients

  • 500 grams all-purpose flour
  • 300 grams active sourdough starter at equal weights flour and water
  • 200 grams lukewarm water, about 95°F
  • 10 grams fine salt
  • 1 tablespoon malt syrup or honey, optional
  • 2 quarts water for boiling
  • 1 tablespoon baking soda
  • 2 tablespoons sesame seeds, poppy seeds, or everything bagel seasoning, optional; or 1 tablespoon coarse sea salt

Condensed Instructions

  1. Mix the starter, water, optional malt syrup or honey, flour, and salt. Rest for 15 minutes.
  2. Knead for 8 to 10 minutes until smooth and firm. Cover and rise for about 4 to 6 hours, until puffier and lighter.
  3. Divide into 8 pieces, shape into balls, rest for 10 minutes, then form rings with openings about 2 inches wide.
  4. Cover and proof for about 1 to 2 hours, until puffy and floating in cool water.
  5. Heat the oven to 425°F. Bring 2 quarts water to a simmer, stir in the baking soda, and boil bagels for 30 seconds per side.
  6. Add toppings, if using. Bake at 425°F for 20 to 25 minutes until deeply golden. Cool on a rack before slicing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make these bagels without malt syrup or honey?
Yes. Both are optional and mainly add a touch of flavor and sweetness. Leave them out without changing the rest of the method.

Can I use sourdough discard?
Only if the discard is active and bubbly enough to raise dough. Unfed discard is often too weak for this recipe on its own. Feed it and wait until it has risen before mixing, or expect a much longer, less predictable rise.

How do I know when the starter is ready?
It should show bubbles throughout and have risen after feeding. A small piece of dough should also become lighter and puffy during the bulk rise. The float test can help judge shaped bagels, but dough appearance and feel matter too.

Do I have to do the float test?
No. It is a practical check, not a requirement. A properly proofed bagel usually looks slightly expanded and feels airy. If it sinks, return it to the covered tray and let it proof longer.

Can I use bread flour instead of all-purpose flour?
Yes. Use the same weight. Bread flour generally gives a firmer, chewier result. Knead until smooth, and add water only if the dough is too dry to come together.

Can I cold-proof the dough?
Yes. Shape the bagels, cover them well, and refrigerate overnight. Bring them out while the oven and water heat, then check that they look puffy before boiling. If they are still tight, allow more time at room temperature.

Why add baking soda to the water?
The alkaline bath helps the bagels develop a browned, characteristic exterior. It also sets the surface before baking, helping the bagels keep their shape.

Can I freeze the bagels?
Yes. Cool them completely, seal them well, and freeze for up to three months. Slice before freezing if you want to toast individual halves without thawing the whole bagel.

Soft and Chewy Sourdough Bagels: A Step-by-Step Guide
Scroll to top