
This homemade copycat seasoning blend brings together dried herbs, onion, garlic, black pepper, paprika, and sea salt in a savory all-purpose mix. It is quick to stir together, easy to adjust, and useful anywhere you want a little more flavor without opening several spice jars.
The key is to make the herbs and spices similar in size before mixing, so the blend distributes evenly instead of leaving the rosemary in large pieces and the powders at the bottom. The flavor is aromatic and savory, with a gentle peppery warmth, an earthy herbal finish, and enough salt to season food without making every dish taste the same.
Why This Recipe Works
The proportions balance concentrated powders with leafy herbs. Onion and garlic make a dependable savory base, while basil, parsley, oregano, thyme, and rosemary provide a layered herbal flavor. Black pepper adds bite, paprika rounds out the blend, and sea salt brings the ingredients together.
Texture matters in a dry blend. Rosemary leaves are often tougher and larger than the other herbs, so crushing them before mixing helps prevent a mouthful of needles and makes each spoonful more consistent. A small spice grinder or mortar and pestle works well; a few firm presses with your fingers can also break up particularly large pieces.
Mixing the ingredients thoroughly before storage helps distribute the salt and powders through the herbs. Letting the blend rest briefly after mixing gives the ingredients time to settle together, but it does not need to be cooked or toasted. Heat can dull dried herbs and make the fine powders clump, so this is a no-oven recipe.
Ingredients
- 2 tablespoons onion powder
- 2 tablespoons garlic powder
- 1 tablespoon black pepper
- 1 tablespoon dried basil
- 1 tablespoon dried parsley
- 1 tablespoon dried oregano
- 1 tablespoon dried thyme
- 1 tablespoon dried rosemary
- 1 tablespoon paprika
- 1 tablespoon sea salt
Ingredient Notes
Onion powder and garlic powder: These powders give the blend its broad savory base and cling readily to moist foods. Use powders rather than granulated onion or garlic if you want a finer, more even mix. Granulated versions can work, though the finished blend will be coarser. Check that the containers are dry and free of hard clumps before measuring.
Black pepper: Ground black pepper adds a warm, slightly sharp note. A fine or medium grind mixes most evenly. Coarsely cracked pepper is a reasonable substitute if you like a more textured seasoning, but it will not distribute as uniformly.
Dried basil and parsley: Basil contributes a sweet, gently peppery herbal note; parsley softens the stronger herbs and gives the blend a familiar green-herb character. Use dried leaves, not fresh herbs, because fresh herbs contain moisture and are not suitable for this shelf-stable mixture. Dried chives can replace some of the parsley, but they will change the flavor.
Oregano, thyme, and rosemary: These herbs provide the deeper, woodsy side of the blend. Oregano and thyme are usually small enough to mix as they are. Rosemary can be stiff and oversized, so crumble or pulse it briefly before adding it. Marjoram can stand in for oregano, and a little extra thyme can replace rosemary if you do not have it, though the blend will be less piney.
Paprika: Plain sweet paprika adds mellow warmth and color without making the mix hot. Smoked paprika is an option if you want a noticeable smoky flavor; use it as a deliberate variation rather than an exact swap, since it can take over the more delicate herbs.
Sea salt: Fine sea salt blends most evenly with the powders. Coarse crystals may settle or leave salty pockets, so grind them finer first. Salt brands and crystal sizes vary; if yours is especially coarse, measure after grinding. You can also make a lower-salt version by reducing the salt, then season the food itself to taste.
Instructions
- Set out a clean, completely dry bowl, spoon, and storage jar. Keep the ingredients at room temperature and make sure none of the herbs or powders are damp. Moisture can make the mix clump, so dry equipment is more important than any particular room temperature. No oven or stovetop is needed.
- Inspect the dried rosemary and crumble any long, stiff leaves between your fingers. For a finer blend, pulse the rosemary alone in a spice grinder for a few seconds, or crush it with a mortar and pestle. Stop when the pieces are small enough to mix comfortably; do not grind it into a powder, which can make the rosemary flavor dominate.
- Add the onion powder, garlic powder, black pepper, basil, parsley, oregano, thyme, rosemary, paprika, and sea salt to the bowl. Stir for about 1 minute, scraping the bottom and sides. The mixture should look evenly speckled, with no visible mound of powder or salt left at the bottom.
- Rub a small pinch between your fingers and look for large herb pieces or any hard clumps. If you find them, break them up and stir again for about 30 seconds. This check helps catch uneven rosemary or clumped garlic powder before the seasoning is put away.
- Transfer the blend to a dry, airtight jar and close the lid. Let it stand for about 10 minutes before using if you have time; this brief rest lets the ingredients settle together and makes it easier to judge the aroma. The mix is ready right away, and it does not need a curing period.
Servings: about a dozen tablespoon-size uses, depending on how generously you season. Prep time: 5 minutes. Cook time: 0 minutes. Total time: 5 minutes, plus an optional 10-minute rest.
Tips for Success
- Measure herbs loosely. Spoon dried leaves into the tablespoon rather than packing them down. Compressed herbs can make the blend more strongly herbal than intended.
- Break up rosemary first. Its long leaves are the likeliest source of an uneven texture. Crushing just that herb keeps the other leaves intact and aromatic.
- Use a dry spoon every time. A wet spoon can introduce moisture into the jar and cause the powders to cake. If the seasoning is going onto wet food, shake some into a separate dish first.
- Season in stages. The blend already contains salt. Start with a light coating, cook the food, then taste before adding more salt or seasoning.
- Adjust for your salt crystal size. Fine sea salt measures more densely than coarse crystals. If using coarse salt, grind it and measure the ground salt for a closer match.
- Keep the jar away from heat and light. A cupboard is a better home than a shelf beside the stove, where warmth and steam can affect the aroma and encourage clumping.
Troubleshooting
The mix tastes too salty. Saltiness can seem stronger on lightly seasoned food, and coarse salt may have measured unevenly. Stir in more of the unsalted herbs and powders in the same general balance, or use a lighter hand next time. For the current jar, sprinkle it onto unsalted food gradually rather than trying to remove salt from the blend.
The seasoning tastes dusty or harsh. This usually happens when the powders have clumped or when they are used too heavily on a delicate dish. Break up clumps before storing, and start with a small amount on food. For a smoother texture, pulse the finished blend briefly, stopping before the leafy herbs become a fine powder.
The rosemary is too noticeable. Crush it more finely next time, or reduce the amount and replace it with extra parsley or thyme. If the current mix has large pieces, sift them out, grind them separately, and stir them back in gradually.
The blend has formed lumps. A little clumping can happen if moisture gets into the jar. Break up small dry clumps with a clean spoon. If the mixture is damp, smells unusual, or shows visible spoilage, discard it rather than trying to dry or salvage it.
The flavor seems faint. Dried herbs lose aroma over time, especially when stored near heat, light, or air. Smell each ingredient before mixing; if an herb has little aroma in the jar, it will not contribute much to the finished blend. Make a fresh batch with fragrant dried herbs and store it tightly sealed.
Variations
Lower-salt blend: Reduce or leave out the sea salt and salt each dish separately. This gives you more control when seasoning foods that are already salty, such as broth, cheese, or cured ingredients.
More peppery: Add a little extra black pepper for a sharper finish. Make the change in a small portion first so you can judge how the stronger pepper works with the herbs.
Smoky version: Replace the paprika with smoked paprika. Its aroma is more pronounced, so use the altered blend where a smoky note fits, such as roasted vegetables, potatoes, or beans.
Citrus-herb finish: Add finely grated fresh lemon zest directly to a dish when serving rather than putting it in the jar. Fresh zest contains moisture and would shorten the keeping quality of the dry blend.
Coarser rub: Leave the herbs leafy and use coarsely ground black pepper. This gives the seasoning more texture for a roast or a thick piece of fish, though it will be less uniform in a sauce or dressing.
What to Serve With It
Use this blend as an all-purpose seasoning, not just a finishing sprinkle. It suits roasted or sautéed vegetables, potatoes, eggs, beans, rice, and simple soups. Start with a modest amount, then taste once the food is cooked; the blend contains salt, and the right amount depends on the other ingredients and how much food you are seasoning.
For chicken, rub a light coating over the surface with a little oil before roasting or grilling. Cook poultry to an internal temperature of 165°F, checked with a food thermometer in the thickest part. For pork or beef, season before cooking and follow the appropriate safe temperature for the cut; whole cuts of pork, beef, lamb, and veal should reach 145°F followed by a three-minute rest, while ground meat should reach 160°F.
For fish, apply the seasoning shortly before cooking so the salt does not sit on the surface for a long time. Fish should reach 145°F, or be cooked until it is opaque and separates easily with a fork. For eggs, use a pinch in scrambled eggs or an omelet and cook egg dishes to 160°F. The seasoning also works in a vinaigrette: whisk a small pinch with oil and vinegar, then let it sit briefly so the dried herbs soften.
Make-Ahead, Storage and Reheating
This is a dry seasoning blend, so it does not need refrigeration or reheating. Store it in a tightly closed, clean, dry jar in a cool, dark cupboard. Label the jar with the date you mixed it so you can keep track of when it was made. Dried herbs gradually lose aroma, so use the blend while it still smells fragrant and make a smaller batch if you do not use it often.
The refrigerator is not a good place for the jar: repeated temperature changes can encourage condensation when it is opened. Freezing is not necessary for a dry spice blend and can also introduce condensation during thawing. Keep it at room temperature in an airtight container instead.
If you use the seasoning on cooked food, handle the finished dish as a perishable leftover. Refrigerate it within two hours of cooking, or within one hour if it has been sitting in temperatures above 90°F. Keep the refrigerator at 40°F or below and use most cooked leftovers within three to four days. For longer storage, freeze cooked leftovers; three to four months is a useful quality guideline for many cooked dishes. Reheat leftovers to 165°F. These cooked-food timelines do not change how the dry seasoning itself is stored.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this the exact Trader Joe’s formula?
This is a homemade copycat-style blend based on the ingredient list provided here. It is not a claim about a brand’s exact proportions or any proprietary formula. Adjust the salt, pepper, or herbs to suit the food you cook.
Do I need to toast or bake the ingredients?
No. The ingredients are already dried, and the blend is ready after mixing. Toasting can make delicate dried herbs less aromatic and may cause the powders to darken or clump, so keep the process cool and dry.
Can I use fresh herbs?
Not in the storage jar. Fresh herbs contain moisture, so they can make a dry seasoning damp and unsuitable for pantry storage. If you want a fresh-herb flavor, chop fresh herbs into the dish as you cook and keep the jarred blend unchanged.
Can I grind the whole blend?
Yes, if you prefer a fine texture. Pulse it briefly and stop as soon as the larger herb pieces are smaller. Grinding for too long can warm the mixture and turn leafy herbs into a dense powder that is harder to measure evenly.
How much should I use?
There is no fixed amount that suits every food. Begin with a light sprinkle or a small pinch per portion, especially because the mix contains salt. Taste after cooking and add more if the dish needs it.
Can I leave out the salt?
Yes. Omit it and salt each recipe separately. The herbs and spices will still make a useful blend, and leaving out salt is particularly practical when you plan to use it with salty broth, cheese, or other seasoned ingredients.
Can I use this as a marinade?
Mix the seasoning with oil or another marinade liquid just before using it, then refrigerate the food while it marinates. Do not save marinade that has touched raw meat, poultry, or seafood unless it is brought to a boil first. Keep the dry blend separate from raw-food drips.
Does the seasoning replace safe cooking temperatures?
No. Seasoning affects flavor, not food safety. Use a food thermometer for meat, poultry, seafood, and egg dishes, and follow the safe internal temperatures described above.
