What are the two kinds of Catholics?

This article may contain affiliate links. For details, visit our Affiliate Disclosure page.


In the vast landscape of Catholicism, a rich tapestry of beliefs, traditions, and practices weaves together to form a diverse and vibrant community. While united under the umbrella of Catholicism, it is essential to recognize that within this religious tradition, there exist two distinct types of Catholics. These divisions are not divisive in nature, but rather represent diverse expressions of faith and approaches to spirituality. In this blog post, we will embark on a captivating exploration of the two kinds of Catholics, shedding light on their unique characteristics, beliefs, and contributions to the rich tapestry of Catholicism. Join us on this journey as we delve into the intricacies of these two groups and celebrate the diversity that enriches the Catholic faith.

What are the two kinds of Catholics?

Embracing Tradition: Traditionalist Catholics

The first group we encounter in our exploration of the two kinds of Catholics is the Traditionalist Catholics. Rooted in a deep reverence for centuries-old practices and a steadfast commitment to preserving ancient traditions, Traditionalist Catholics offer a unique perspective within the broader Catholic community.

Traditionalist Catholics place great emphasis on the Latin Mass, also known as the Tridentine Mass, which was the standard form of liturgy prior to the Second Vatican Council. They view this form of worship as a sacred link to the historical roots of the Church, cherishing the solemnity, beauty, and transcendence it encapsulates. The Latin Mass is celebrated in a more structured manner, often accompanied by Gregorian chants, incense, and a greater sense of reverence for the Eucharist.

In addition to their liturgical preferences, Traditionalist Catholics hold a strong devotion to the veneration of saints, the recitation of the rosary, and the preservation of traditional devotions. They often seek to maintain a distinct separation between the sacred and the secular, valuing the timeless teachings of the Church and expressing their faith through a disciplined and traditional approach.

The Call for Renewal: Progressive Catholics

As we continue our exploration, we encounter the second group of Catholics known as Progressive Catholics. This subset embraces a more contemporary interpretation of Catholicism, embracing change and advocating for social justice, inclusivity, and a reimagining of certain traditional practices.

Progressive Catholics view the Second Vatican Council as a pivotal moment in the Church’s history, promoting a spirit of renewal and adaptation to the modern world. They embrace vernacular languages in the liturgy, placing an emphasis on active participation by the congregation, and fostering a sense of community within the Church.

With a commitment to social justice and inclusivity, Progressive Catholics actively engage in issues such as poverty, human rights, environmental stewardship, and LGBTQ+ rights. They view the Church as a catalyst for positive change in society and advocate for a more open and inclusive approach to various theological and moral issues.

Progressive Catholics often emphasize the importance of individual conscience and personal discernment, encouraging an ongoing dialogue between faith and the contemporary world. They seek to find a delicate balance between tradition and adaptation, honoring the timeless truths of Catholicism while responding to the evolving needs and challenges of the modern era.

Embracing Tradition: Traditionalist Catholics

Immersed in the echoes of ancient rituals and practices, Traditionalist Catholics embody a deep reverence for the traditions that have been passed down through generations. For them, the Latin Mass holds a sacred place at the center of their worship. Rooted in a sense of continuity with the early Church, Traditionalist Catholics find solace and spiritual nourishment in the solemnity, ritualistic precision, and timeless beauty of the Tridentine Mass.

In the Latin Mass, the language itself becomes a vessel for transcendence, transporting the faithful to a realm that transcends time and space. The Gregorian chants, performed in harmonious unison, evoke a sense of awe and wonder, lifting the hearts and minds of worshippers toward the divine. The liturgy is celebrated with meticulous attention to detail, accompanied by the intoxicating aroma of incense that fills the air, adding to the atmosphere of sacredness and holiness.

Traditionalist Catholics hold a profound devotion to the saints, seeking their intercession and drawing inspiration from their exemplary lives of faith. They find comfort and strength in the recitation of the rosary, a meditative prayer that invites contemplation of the mysteries of Christ’s life, death, and resurrection. Their daily lives are often punctuated by traditional devotions such as novenas, processions, and pilgrimages, which provide spiritual sustenance and deepen their connection to the rich tapestry of Catholic tradition.

The Call for Renewal: Progressive Catholics

In contrast to Traditionalist Catholics, Progressive Catholics embrace a more dynamic and contemporary expression of their faith. Inspired by the transformative spirit of the Second Vatican Council, they see the need to adapt the Church’s practices and teachings to the evolving world and engage with the pressing social and ethical issues of our time.

Progressive Catholics welcome the use of vernacular languages in the liturgy, fostering a sense of accessibility and inclusivity among the congregation. The Mass becomes a communal celebration, with active participation encouraged through communal responses, hymns, and lay involvement in various ministries.

A hallmark of Progressive Catholicism is a strong commitment to social justice and a desire to bring about positive change in the world. They strive to embody the Gospel values of compassion, solidarity, and mercy by actively engaging with issues such as poverty, inequality, and environmental stewardship. Progressive Catholics advocate for the dignity and rights of all individuals, including marginalized groups, and promote a more inclusive and welcoming Church for LGBTQ+ individuals.

Within the realm of theology and moral teachings, Progressive Catholics engage in ongoing dialogue and critical reflection. They recognize the importance of individual conscience and personal discernment, inviting the faithful to grapple with complex ethical dilemmas and engage in open discussions on matters such as contraception, divorce, and women’s roles in the Church. They seek to find a delicate balance between tradition and adaptation, always guided by the fundamental principles of love, justice, and the pursuit of the common good.


In the rich tapestry of Catholicism, the presence of two distinct types of Catholics reflects the diversity and complexity of the global Catholic community. Traditionalist Catholics uphold centuries-old traditions, emphasizing the Latin Mass and preserving ancient devotions, while Progressive Catholics embrace change, social justice, and a more contemporary approach to faith.

While these two groups may express their faith in different ways, their shared commitment to the core beliefs and teachings of Catholicism unites them under the broader Catholic umbrella. Both Traditionalist and Progressive Catholics contribute to the vibrant tapestry of Catholicism, enriching the Church with their unique perspectives and approaches. As we celebrate the diversity within Catholicism, let us recognize and embrace the beauty and richness that emerge from the coexistence of these two distinct types of Catholics. Through mutual respect, dialogue, and a shared love for the faith, Traditionalist and Progressive Catholics can continue to learn from one another, fostering a spirit of unity and a deeper understanding of the beauty that lies at the heart of Catholicism.

What are the two kinds of Catholics?
Scroll to top