Why Is The MLB Exempt From Antitrust Laws?

This article may contain affiliate links. For details, visit our Affiliate Disclosure page.

The exemption of Baseball’s Major League (MLB) from the U.S antitrust laws was in 1922. Other professional sports leagues are subject to some antitrust exemptions, but none are as comprehensive as those for professional baseball. Baseball faces the same problems as other sports, even though applying antitrust legislation to sports can be difficult at times. Let us know ‘Why Is The MLB Exempt From Antitrust Laws?’.

Why Is The MLB Exempt From Antitrust Laws?

The Federal League In 1915 filed a lawsuit against MLB, based on breaking the Sherman Act by monopolizing the industry for sportsmen. According to the Federal League, MLB was preventing it from hiring baseball players. The Federal League was acquired by Major League Baseball as part of the parties’ agreement. In addition to the league’s collapse, the owners of the new league got the cash.

What Is MLB?

Major League Baseball is referred to as MLB. When management and employees have a collective bargaining agreement effelaborbour law governs rather than antitrust law, and major league players are represented by a union.

American Antitrust Law

The purpose of antitrust laws is to prevent businesses from engaging in anti-competitive behavior. MLB has kept its exemption in place since 1922.

The three most vital antitrust laws in the US combined to fulfill its fundamental goal of avoiding monopolization and advancing a competitive marketplace. These laws include the Clayton Act of 1914, the Trade Commission Act of 1914, and the Sherman Act of 1890.

  • The Sherman Act is still the most well-known antitrust statute, having been passed in 1890. Any contract, accumulation in the manner of trust, or bribery impeding trade or business among several States or with foreign countries is prohibited, according to Section 1 of the Act.
  • A monopoly cannot be created (or attempted to be created), according to the Act. The Act’s Section 2 gave a stern warning on monopolizing, or any means of joining or conspiring with any other individual to dominate any part of the industry among the different States, or foreign nations.
  • A Commission Act which was passed in 1914 on Federal Trade, birthed the Federal Trade Commission. The Commission, which has five members who serve terms of seven years, is responsible for enforcing antitrust laws.
  • The most important thing to keep in mind is that these antitrust laws only cover intrastate trade and commerce, not trade and business between states. These laws restrict interstate trade.

This difference allowed for the MLB’s special antitrust exemption.

Why Is The MLB Exempt From Antitrust Laws?

Major League Baseball was exempted from the Sherman Act, which prohibits businesses from banding together to suppress competition, as a result of a 1922 Supreme Court ruling that claimed, somewhat implausibly, that the league’s operations did not constitute “interstate trade.”

Kennesaw Mountain Landis, the first commissioner of Major League Baseball, presided over the court case involving the Federal League. The teams were purchased by Major League Baseball, except one, and merged with the former Leagues. The dispute was resolved to lead to the dismissal of the case.

A gift from Congress and the Supreme Court has been the golden goose for Major League Baseball’s exemption for over a century now. This allows it to virtually operate as a monopoly.

This has been Major League Baseball’s unsung hero, best kept unknown and unheard of—at least until sometimes finding something about the league with which they disagree and making vague threats to revoke it.

Regardless of political affiliation, anyone could make these threats. Some right-wing US senators proposed legislation to hinder MLB from moving its All-star Game from Atlanta. The league has been under fire from progressive independent Bernie Sanders for underpaying minor league players and closing minor league franchises.

The Federal League had been suing the major leagues for seven years, but the case had not yet been heard by the judge who would later become baseball’s commissioner, Kenesaw Mountain Landis.

The Challenges

  • Even before the MLB became one of the nation’s most powerful unions, players had significantly fewer alternatives for bringing claims against the major leagues.
  • The judicial system is used for handling premature trials by some of the players to procure free agency and, in a broader term, to fight the antitrust exemption.
  • The Baseball Club of Baltimore National League is where the exemption was first recognized in the Supreme Court’s 1922. As interstate commerce was not how baseball operated, the Court held in that instance that baseball was exempt from the federal antitrust laws.
  • Nearly 25 years after Curt Flood, who had just been traded from the St. Louis Cardinals to the Philadelphia Phillies, had challenged the reserve clause before the Supreme Court, baseball would eventually come to its senses—at least regarding the reserve clause.
  • In 2018, the highest court rejected several lesser-known challenges to the antitrust clause, including those made by nearby Wrigley Field property owners who claimed the Chicago Cubs’ plans for expansion would block their prized and lucrative views of the stadium and by a group of baseball scouts who alleged MLB clubs were conspiring to stifle salaries.

Exemption for Major League Baseball

  • The American League and the National League are presently governed by the MLB organization following the season in 1999, merged with Major League Baseball and have since that time disappeared as a sovereign organization.
  • Three leagues exist In the early 20th century for a brief period. In addition to the first two, there was also the Federal League. The Federal League was established to compete with the existing Leagues in Baseball in 1913.
  • The Federal League team owners, Baltimore Terrapins, have received a tiny share of the compensation money. The organization rejected the agreement as unfair. It continued to insist that MLB was breaking antitrust laws and initiated a lawsuit against the league.
  • During the Federal Baseball Club National League (1922), the Supreme Court ruled out MLB from the antitrust laws.
In Conclusion

Unlike other sports, baseball has a special significance for Americans, and while there are instances of judges and legislators expressing their passion for the game, there is much more to baseball’s exemption. Baseball was not considered interstate commerce, the court unanimously decided. It was a business-related issue for them. Baseball was played exclusively inside states, not between states. To play each other, teams had to travel between states, although this was just considered a minor nuisance and not a crucial component of the business.

Frequently Asked Questions
  • MLB losing its exemption from antitrust laws, what would happen?

MLB’s attempt to keep minor league earnings below the federal league minimum wage would be illegal.

  • Why is MLB a monopoly, exactly?

Given permission to establish a monopoly on professional baseball, the National League, MLB was able to fix wages, coordinate prices, and ensure that there was no viable competition.

Why Is The MLB Exempt From Antitrust Laws?
Scroll to top